British Irish RIGHTS WATCH#

TOPCONFLICT-RELATED DEATHS SINCE THE CEASEFIRETOP

     

# Back # Previous # Home #Next#

 

CASES

Date

Name

Age

Sex

Reli-gion

Affili-ation

Alleged Perpe-trator

Location Town / Area

Location County / Country

Details

 

Category

Arrests / Prosecutions

     

Sources

Arrest / Prosecution Details

27-Jan-94 Cormac McDermott 31 M C   UVF Ballymena Co. Antrim

McDermott was shot at his home by the UVF [1]

His wife was shot twice in the throat but survived.  Their 3½ year old daughter witnessed the attack [2]

He was the son-in-law of Larne Cllr. William Cunning who received letter bomb in 1991 [3]

A 31 year old man was sentenced to life imprisonment of the murder of McDermott and the attempted murder of Mrs McDermott, and possession of weapon [4]

[1] CAIN, University of Ulster

[2] Lost Lives, p 1344

[3] Relatives for justice. 

www.relativesforjustice.com

21-May-94 Martin Doherty 35 M   IRA UVF Pearse St. Dublin Republic of Ireland Doherty was shot by the UVF, who were trying to plant a bomb in Widow Scallon's pub [1] Three men tried to enter the bar with a 15kg bomb [2] A sinn Fein event was being held inside at the time [3] Another man was wounded in the attack [4] His sister alleges an unmasked Garda car was seen leaving the area 20 minutes before the attack [5] No one was ever arrested for his murder.  The inquest into his death took 10 years

[1] IRA member shot while stopping bombs, Belfast Telegraph, 04 November 2004

 

[2] CAIN, University of Ulster

 

[3] IRA member shot while stopping bombers, Irish Independent, 04 November 2004

31-Aug-94

Sean MacDermott

37

M

C

Civilian

UVF

Antrim

Co Antrim

Mr MacDermott was abducted from the house where he was lodging in Antrim. A gang broke in the door with sledgehammers, dragged him from his bed, and bound him with tape before taking him away. He was later found dead in a car, shot twice in the head with a shotgun.[1]

[1] Lost Lives, by David McKittrick, Seamus Kelters, Brian Feeney, and Chris Thornton, Mainstream Publishing, Edinburgh, 1999, no. 3517

01-Sep-94

John O’Hanlon

32

M

C

Civilian

UFF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot from passing vehicle while working on a friend’s car on Skegoneill Road in North Belfast. The UFF claimed Mr O’Hanlon was a ‘known Republican’. At the inquest, however, the Coroner disputed this claim, saying there was “no basis of fact in it at all.” At the same time, he said that the only possible conclusion was that it was a sectarian murder. The gun used by the killer had been linked to other attacks in North Belfast between March and September 1994.[1]

[1] UFF blasted for ‘sectarian killing’ of last victim, Irish News, 22 June 1995

10-Nov-94

Frank Kerr

54

M

C

Civilian

IRA

Newry

Co Down

Postal worker killed during a bungled £130,000 robbery of the Newry sorting office. Mr Kerr struggled with one of the robbers, who had tied up several workers inside the sorting office, and was shot in the head. The IRA admitted the robbery and killing but denied it was a breach of the ceasefire, claiming a breakdown in their chain of command.[1]

Two men, Declan McComish (28) and Kevin Patrick Donegan (39) were arrested with Mr Kerr’s bloodstained uniform in their possession. In December 1996, they were found not guilty of murder, but were convicted of assisting the IRA killers.[2] Mr Donegan was sentenced to eight years and six and a half years and Mr McComish was sentenced to five and a half years and four years, to run concurrently, for assisting the killing and for their part in the robbery respectively[3]. Mr Donegan was released in 1998 under the Good Friday Agreement[4].

   

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3519

[2] Two cleared of killing PO man, by Brenda O’Neill, Irish News, 5 December 1996

[3] Pair jailed for helping PO man’s IRA killers, by Brenda O’Neill, Irish News, 14 December 1996

[4] IRA hunger striker freed in peace deal, by John Mullin, Guardian, 22 October 1998

12-Dec-94

Malachy Martin Clark

17

M

C

Civilian

Self inflicted

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Hanged himself after a so-called punishment beating by a group of IRA men (on 21 October 1994) for glue-sniffing that left him in the hospital with a broken nose and ruptured eardrum[1]. Left a note saying that the beating drove him to suicide[2].

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3520

[2] Ulster beatings: No truce in sight; IRA, Loyalists using violence to keep control, by Ray Moseley, Chicago Tribune, 28 May 1995

22-Dec-94

Noel Lyness

47

M

C

Civilian

Loyalists?

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Assaulted, assumedly with a breeze block found at the scene. The killing is believed to have been sectarian.[1] The murder was not believed to have been sanctioned by the UVF, UDA or Red Hand Commando, but was believed to have been committed by a non-specific loyalist group [2].

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3521

[2] Hatred awaits decommissioning as ceasefires hold, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 29 December 1994

http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/sutton/chron/1994/html

02-Mar-95

James (Jim) Seymour

55

M

P

RUC

IRA

Outside Coalisland RUC base

Co Tyrone

RUC man died 22 years after being shot in the head on 4 May 1973 by a gunman who opened fire as Mr Seymour was returning to duty at the RUC station. He remained paralyzed in hospital throughout the 22 year period.[1]

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3522

28-Apr-95

Michael (Mickey) Mooney

34

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

Belfast city centre

Co Antrim

Shot while at a bar by two unmasked gunman who escaped on foot. Mr Mooney was thought to have been targeted because he was reportedly the leader of one of the largest drug gangs in Northern Ireland.[1] This was the first murder claimed by the IRA using the cover name Direct Action Against Drugs[2].

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3523

[2] 13 victims of the Provos’ policing drive, by Maeve Connolly, Irish News, 23 February 2002

05-Sep-95

Anthony (Tony) Kane

29

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

West Belfast

Co Antrim

A known drug dealer shot while waiting with his wife in his car outside a church after his aunt’s funeral. Mr Kane had reportedly been an acquaintance of Mickey Mooney.[1]

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Belfast drugs dealer shot dead after funeral, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 6 September 1995

28-Sep-95

William (Billy) Elliott

32

M

P

RHC

RHC

Bangor

Co Down

Shot twice in the head at close range, allegedly for his part in the band hall murder of Margaret Wright, a Protestant woman falsely believed to be Catholic, in April 1994. Frankie Curry, a leading figure in the Red Hand Commando, said he killed Billy Elliot.  He was the RHC leader in the Donegal area [1]

Thomas Maginnis (38) was charged with the murders of Mr Elliott, Mark Sweeney, Brian O’Rawe, and William Paul, as well as conspiracy to murder and wound, possession of guns, robbery, theft and arson. He had made admissions during secretly recorded conversations with police about the murders, and confessed to some of the murders on being confronted with the taped admission. In October 2000, this man was freed by Belfast Crown Court Lord Justice McCollum, who ruled that the accused would probably not get a fair trial because of inappropriate tactics used by the police in obtaining a confession.[2]

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3525

[2] Murder accused freed despite confession, by Anne McClean, Irish News, 2 October 2000

[3] 'Judges frees man who confessed to four murders' by David Sharrock, The Telegraph, 30 September 2000

 

07-Nov-95 Edward McCloskey 31 M C Civilian Self-induced Strathroy Park North Belfast Died from carbon monoxide poisoning after committing suicide in his car following a punishment beating from the IRA 3 months earlier.  The coroner confirmed there was no evidence to suggest Mr McCloskey had been involved in drugs [1]         [1] IRA beating led to suicide-inquest in the Irish Times, 7January 1996  

27-Nov-95

Norman Harley

45

M

C

Civilian

Loyalists

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Assaulted and killed with an iron bar on his way home to Castleton Gardens. The killing did not involve paramilitary groups, but originally seemed to have sectarian motives.[1] A judge later disputed this claim during the sentencing of two men convicted of murder and manslaughter[2].

In June 1997, Christopher MacMillan (22) was convicted of murder and jailed for life. Mark Bellringer (22) was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to seven years. The judge ruled it was not a sectarian attack, but was probably to get money for alcohol. Mr Bellringer was also sentenced to four years for causing grievous bodily harm to another man on the same evening in the same park. Bellringer was the first man to be released under the Good Friday Agreement [3]

   

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3526

[2] Life sentence for ‘vicious’ murder, Irish Times, 22 June 1997

[3] Life sentence for ‘vicious’ murder, Irish Times, 22 June 1997 http://archives.tcm.ie/irishexaminer/1998/09/12/ihead.htm

08-Dec-95

Paul 'Saul' Devine

35

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot up to six times in the back and once in the head after he had fallen. Mr Devine was presumably shot because he was reportedly involved in drug dealing. Known associate of Mickey Mooney.[1] One source said police believed he was killed by INLA members working for the IRA, and that he was a member of a gang who helped the IRA by carrying out hijackings and robberies, then handing over a cut of the proceeds[2].

Joe Hendron (SDLP MP) claimed the murder constituted a breach of the IRA ceasefire[3]

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3527

[2] Bargaining in blood, by John Davison, Andrew Grice and Ciaran Byrne, Sunday Times, 7 January 1996

[3] http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/othelem/chron/ch95.htm

18-Dec-95

Francis Collins

40

M

C

Former IRA

IRA / DAAD

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot by two unmasked gunmen in front of his fish and chip shop, where he and his wife were working. The killing was supposedly drugs-related, but his wife claims that it arose from a personal vendetta by individuals within the republican movement. A detective sergeant said that there was no evidence of drug involvement, and it might have been a case of mistaken identity.[1] Mr Collins had been involved with IRA bombings and shootings in the 1970s[2].

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] Widow vows to clear husband’s ‘drugs smear’, by Brendan Anderson, Irish News, 29 May 1996

[2] Lost Lives, no. 3528

19-Dec-95

Christopher ‘Sid’ Johnson

38

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot by two gunmen in front of his home in drugs-related circumstances. At the time of his death, Mr Johnson was on bail, after having been charged with possession of £250,000 worth of cannabis.[1] There were conflicting reports on whether the charges had been dropped. DAAD, however, claimed to have committed the murder because Mr Johnson was dealing drugs.[2]

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3529

[2] Confusion on status of charges against man shot in Belfast, by Gerry Moriarty and Geraldine Kennedy, Irish Times, 21 December 1995

27-Dec-95

Martin McCrory

30

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Killed by double shotgun blast in the living room of his home while watching television. Traces of ecstasy were found in his bloodstream, consistent with ‘recreational use’, but an RUC Det Inspector told the inquest that his involvement in drug dealing had reportedly ceased a few years before his death.[1] Mr McCrory had previously been the victim of a punishment attack[2].

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Gun victim had traces of Ecstasy in blood, Irish News, 7 January 1998

[2] Lost Lives, no. 3530

02-Jan-96

Ian Lyons

31

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

Lurgan

Co Armagh

Killed in his car by two masked gunmen in a drugs-related shooting as he sat with his girlfriend outside her home. Mr Lyons’ family denied he had any drug involvement, and the RUC said he was known to them in only general terms.[1]

 

Drugs-related killing?

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3531

31-Jan-96

Gino Gallagher

32

M

C

INLA

INLA

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot four times in the back of the head as he signed on at the Falls Road Social Security Office[1]. This killing was part of an INLA internal feud between Gino Gallagher and Hugh Torney’s factions after Hugh Torney had been ousted as chief of staff of INLA. Numerous people were shot and/or killed over the next eight months as part of this feud.[2]

 

INLA feud

Charles Kevin Begley of Belfast was accused of the murder and went on trial at Belfast Crown Court, but the charge was dropped because he pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of conspiring to murder a person or persons unknown. Mr Begley was also convicted and sentenced to 11 years for planning another murder.[3]

   

[1] Gallagher murder ‘an unbelievably clean killing’, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 3 February 1996

[2] GHQ faction statement says deadly feud with INLA is over, by Gerry Moriarty and Carol Coulter, Irish Times, 11 September 1996

[3] Man jailed for murder plot, Irish Times, 16 October 1997

09-Feb-96

John Jefferies

31

M

U

Civilian

IRA

Docklands, London

England

Killed when an approximately 1,000 pound IRA bomb exploded near Canary Wharf in Docklands, London. This was the end of the IRA ceasefire, which had lasted 17 months. The IRA issued a statement and bomb warning a short time before the bomb went off, but this did not allow enough time to clear the area.[1]

A 34-year-old man and James McCardle (29) were charged with conspiring to cause an explosion likely to endanger life or cause serious injury to property. Mr McCardle was also charged with murdering Inan Bashir and John Jeffries. The 34-year-old man was acquitted after the judge ruled there was insufficient evidence against him.[2] In a retrial after the first jury failed to reach a verdict, Mr McCardle was sentenced to 25 years for the conspiracy charge. The jury was not allowed to consider the murder charge because of press coverage.[3] Mr McCardle was released from the Maze prison in July 2000 as part of the Good Friday Agreement’s early release scheme for paramilitary prisoners[4].

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3534

[2] Retrial in Docklands bomb case as jury fail to reach a verdict, Irish Times, 21 February 1998

[3] Voters Backing Peace, Undeterred by Blasts, by Christopher Henning, Sydney Morning Herald, 26 June 1998

[4] Symbol of a painful peace: Largest one-day exodus in 30 years sees 78 freed from Maze, by John Mullin, Guardian, 29 July 2000

Patrick McKinley (34 in 1998)

09-Feb-96

Inan Ul-Haq Bashir

29

M

U

Civilian

IRA

Docklands, London

England

Killed when an IRA bomb exploded near Canary Wharf in Docklands, London[1]. (see above)

(see above)

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3533

18-Feb-96

Edward O’Brien

21

M

C

IRA

Self inflicted

Aldwych, London

England

Killed when his own bomb exploded, assumedly prematurely, in a bus in central London. After his death, security forces found Semtex, timers, detonators, and ammunition in his London home. Five other people were injured in the explosion.[1]

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3535

04-Mar-96

John Fennell

40

M

C

INLA

INLA

Bundoran, Co Donegal

Republic of Ireland

One of the founders of INLA, battered to death with breeze blocks at a caravan site in Bundoran after supposedly ‘confessing’ to Gino Gallagher’s death under torture. This was done as part of the INLA feud.[1] A companion disappeared for several days, but was found safe, his head covered and hands bound, on 8 March[2].

 

INLA feud

A man in his 20s was questioned by Gardai, but released on 8 April 1996[3].

   

[1] Belfast shooting may be latest in republican faction feud, The Herald (Glasgow), 15 April 1996

[2] Gardai locate man who disappeared after killing, Irish Times, 9 March 1996

[3] Man held in Fennell murder, Irish Times, 9 April 1996

15-Mar-96

Barbara McAlorum

9

F

C

Civilian

INLA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

9-year-old shot by a spray of gunfire as she was playing with a jigsaw puzzle in the living room of her home. The shooting was associated with the INLA internal feud, and the gunman was believed to have belonged to Gino Gallagher’s faction of INLA. A 19-year-old man visiting the house, Ciaran Scott, was injured in the shooting.[1] Her father was targeted with a bomb in May 1996 while visiting his son at Maghaberry prison[2].

 

INLA feud

A number of men were arrested and questioned in the weeks following the killing, but were released without charge[3].

   

[1] Tragic scene parents wanted world to see, by Colin O’Carroll, Irish News, 19 March 1996

[2] Gino men get bomb blame, by Brenda O’Neill, Irish News, 18 May 1996

[3] Lost Lives, no. 3537

21-Mar-96

Thomas (Tommy) Sheppard

41

M

P

UVF

UVF

Ballymena

Co Antrim

Killed by three shots fired by two gunmen in a bar in Ballymena. Security sources claimed that loyalist paramilitaries were involved.[1] The Sunday Times from the week of 24 March 1996 claimed the UVF had carried out the killing because they believed Mr Sheppard was an informer[2].

Police were questioning one man shortly after the killing.[3]

   

[1] RUC question man in loyalist's murder, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 23 March 1996

[2] Lost Lives, no. 3538

[3] RUC question man in loyalist's murder, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 23 March 1996

25-May-96

Dessie McCleery

37

M

C

INLA

INLA

Central Belfast

Co Antrim

Hugh Torney’s deputy, who was shot in the crowded bar of a pizza restaurant in central Belfast by the INLA faction loyal to Gino Gallagher[1].

 

INLA feud

A 30-year-old man was charged with involvement in the murder in 1996[2]. In December, 1997, he was acquitted of the murder. His girlfriend, however, was sentenced to community service for providing a false alibi for him.[3]

     

[1] INLA rivals fight it out for power and vengeance, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 27 May 1996

[2] INLA murder judgment reserved, Irish Times, 5 December 1997

[3] Conviction for false alibi, Irish Times, 31 January 1998

Brendan Patrick Gallagher (30 in 1996), brother of Gino Gallagher

07-Jun-96

Gerard (Jerry) McCabe

52

M

C

An Garda Síochána

IRA

Adare, Co Limerick

Republic of Ireland

Hit by three of the fourteen bullets fired during a robbery of an An Post truck carrying £100,000 in pension and social security money which he and a colleague were guarding. Some months after the attack, the IRA admitted that some of its members carried out the killing.[1]

Four men, Kevin Walsh, Pearse McAuley, Jeremiah Sheedy and Michael O'Neill, pleaded guilty to manslaughter fifteen days into the trial, 3 February 1999, and were given sentences of 11-14 years[2]. A fifth man, John Quinn, was sentenced to four years for conspiracy to rob[3]. In March 2003, the High Court rejected a Sinn Féin bid for the early release under the Belfast Agreement for two men jailed in connection with the robbery in which Mr McCabe was killed[4].

   

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3540

[2] Lost Lives, no. 3540

[3] IRA backs away from legal battle over McCabe killers, by John Mooney, Sunday Times, 27 August 2000

[4] Garda's killer to challenge sentence, by Mary Carolan, Irish Times, 29 March 2003

09-Jun-96

Francis Shannon

23

M

C

INLA

INLA

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot at close range in Turf Lodge by Gino Gallagher’s INLA faction as part of the INLA internal feud. Mr Shannon’s natural father was John Fennell, who was killed in March 1996.[1] When he was killed, Mr Shannon was wearing a wig in order to disguise himself and was wearing a bullet-proof vest[2].

 

INLA feud

   

[1] Man shot dead on Belfast street in INLA feud, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 10 June 1996

[2] INLA murder victim was wearing a wig, The Herald (Glasgow), 11 June 1996

08-Jul-96

Michael McGoldrick

31

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Lurgan

Co Armagh

Taxi driver shot in the run-up to the 1996 Drumcree crisis. Mr McGoldrick was taking a passenger to a predominantly Catholic village outside of Lurgan and was lured into a small back lane, where the driver of another car got into the taxi and shot Mr McGoldrick five times in the back of the head.[1]

Clifford McKeown, a LVF member who was an associate of Billy Wright, was charged with the murder on 6 November 2001. He was convicted and sentenced to 24 years in April 2003, but the sentence may be reduced under the terms of the Good Friday agreement. Mr McKeown planned to appeal the sentence. The conviction came primarily from evidence presented by journalist Nick Martin Clark, to whom McKeown admitted the killings, which he described as a ‘birthday present’ for Wright.[2]

   

[1] Loyalist murderer jailed for 27 years, by Damlin Henderson, The Herald, 10 April 2003

[2] Loyalist murderer jailed for 27 years, by Damien Henderson, The Herald, 10 April 2003

12-Jul-96

Thomas Annett

34

M

P

UDA

Loyalists

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Assaulted outside a bar on Ormeau Road. Police said the killing was not sectarian, but associates and family members believed that the killing was a result of loyalist paramilitary involvement.[1]

A 30-year-old man was charged with the murder on 20 November 1997[2]. In August 2001, this same man was charged with possessing documents useful to terrorists. These documents supposedly emanated from British army spy Brian Nelson.[3]

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3543

[2] Man charged with Belfast murder, Irish Times, 20 November 1997

[3] Court releases three on bail, Irish News, 25 August 2001

Colin Stephen Lindsay (30 in 1997)

13-Jul-96

Dermot 'Tonto' McShane

35

M

C

Former INLA

Army

Derry

Co Derry

Killed in Derry during the Drumcree riots when an army vehicle drove into a piece of corrugated metal behind which Mr McShane was sheltering[1].

In 1998, the Director of Public Prosecution decided not to prosecute the driver of the vehicle[2]. In 2002, in McShane v. the United Kingdom, the European Court of Human Rights unanimously ruled that the UK had violated Mr McShane’s right to life by failing to effectively investigate his death. Mr McShane’s wife was awarded £8,000 in damages and £8,000 in costs.[3]

   

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3544

[2] Lost Lives, no. 3544

[3] Court finds man's right to life violated, Irish Times, 29 May 2002

03-Sep-96

Hugh Torney

41

M

C

INLA

INLA

Lurgan

Co Armagh

Shot by gunmen from Gino Gallagher’s INLA faction outside a house in Lurgan, Co Armagh, as part of the internal INLA feud between his faction and Gino Gallagher’s faction. Mr Torney had been ousted as INLA chief of staff by Gino Gallagher, and had reportedly ordered Gino Gallagher’s assassination in January 1996.[1]

 

INLA feud

Three men were questioned about the murder, but released without charge[2]. Liam McAnoy, the man accompanying Mr Torney when Mr Torney died and who was wounded in the attack, went on trial in 1997 on an arms charges relating to the event in question[3]. In February 1998, Mr McAnoy was sentenced to six and a half years in prison[4].

   

[1] INLA feud takes another ‘best friend’, by Henry McDonald, Sunday Times, 8 September 1996

[2] RUC frees trio of suspects, Irish News, 11 December 1996

[3] Man shot in attack faces gun charges, by Brendan Anderson, Irish News, 10 December 1997

[4] Man jailed for possessing gun, Irish Times, 10 February 1998

16-Sep-96

John Paul ‘Sean’ Devlin

31

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot three times in the head by two masked men in a house in Friendly Street, the day before he was to appear in court on drugs charges. The IRA had supposedly threatened him to leave Northern Ireland or be shot.[1]

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Drugs group admits murder in Belfast, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 17 September 1996

21-Sep-96

Kenneth Auld

47

M

P

Civilian

Republicans

Glenarm

Co Antrim

Died four days after he was stabbed with screwdriver while trying to stop republicans removing an Ulster flag from a post outside the Masonic Hall[1].

A 26-year-old man who was charged with the killing claimed he was drunk at the time, then was himself struck on the head with a flagpole, and thus remembers nothing of the incident[2]. He was subsequently acquitted[3].

     

[1] Glenarm flag row stabbing horror, by John Breslin, Belfast Telegraph, 17 September 1996

[2] Flag row ‘triggered fatal screwdriver attack’, by Brenda O’Neill, Irish News, 5 December 1997

[3] Attacks continue in North Antrim, An Phoblacht/Republican News, 15 January 1998

Gregory Oliver O’Neill (26 in 1997)

22-Sep-96

George Scott

32

M

P

UVF?

Unknown

Cookstown

Co Tyrone

Beaten to death in his flat in a ‘failed’ punishment beating for previous fights and threats[1].

Two of the accused, Robert Stewart (39) and George Watterson (31) pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 1998. The murder cases against three men, Gary McGuckin (31), Mark McGuckin (36), and Rodger Crooks (24) went to trial in January 1998[2]. Mark McGuckin was found guilty of murder, while Gary McGuckin and Rodger Crooks were found guilty of a lesser charge of manslaughter[3].

   

[1] Man killed in ‘failed’ punishment beating, by Brendan Anderson, Irish News, 28 January 1998

[2] Man killed in ‘failed’ punishment beating, by Brendan Anderson, Irish News, 28 January 1998

[3] Murder and manslaughter verdicts for beating gang, by Martin Anderson, Irish News, 1 July 1998

23-Sep-96

Diarmuid O’Neill

27

M

C

IRA

Metropolitan police

Hammersmith, London

England

Unarmed IRA member shot six times during a botched arrest operation in a Hammersmith hotel in which the duplicate room key did not work, the battering ram broke a hole in the door without opening the door, and 10 rounds of CS gas were thrown into the room, impeding the vision of the arresting officers.[1]

In February 2000, a jury exonerated the police officers, ruling that Mr O’Neill was lawfully shot during this arrest operation even though the operation went ‘badly wrong’[2]. The Crown Prosecution Service decided not to prosecute the officer who shot Mr O’Neill. Friends and family members are campaigning for a full inquiry into the death.[3]

   

[1] Police killing of IRA man 'lawful'; Inquest verdict on unarmed terrorist suspect shot in hotel, by Nick Hopkins, Guardian, 19 February 2000

[2] Police killing of IRA man 'lawful'; Inquest verdict on unarmed terrorist suspect shot in hotel, by Nick Hopkins, Guardian, 19 February 2000

[3] No trial for officer who shot IRA man, by Duncan Campbell, Guardian, 27 April 1999

10-Oct-96

Darren Murray

12

M

C

Civilian

Unknown

Portadown

Co Armagh

Died two days after being struck by van during a confrontation between nationalist and loyalist children shouting taunts at each other[1].

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3550

11-Oct-96

James Bradwell

43

M

U

Army

IRA

Lisburn

Co Antrim

Warrant officer killed by car bombs at Thiepval barracks, the British Army headquarters in Lisburn, Co Antrim. Mr Bradwell died four days after attack, in which 31 other people were injured.[1]

One man was charged with conspiring to cause the explosion, but failed to return to court in 1997[2]. As of 2002, he was still a fugitive and appeared on the list of fugitives Sinn Féin submitted to the government for amnesty[3].

     

[1] IRA ‘aimed to wipe out casualties’, by Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 25 November 1996

[2] IRA ‘aimed to wipe out casualties’, by Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 25 November 1996

[3] IRA fugitives at heart of amnesty dispute, The Times, 13 March 2002

Michael Gerard Rogan

29-Oct-96

Thomas Stewart

32

M

P

UVF

UVF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot near his home in north Belfast less than a week after he was ‘stood down’ by the UVF as a party leader[1]. A year later, after Jackie Mahood was shot, the spokesperson for the Progressive Unionist Party linked the cases, suggesting that ‘criminal elements’ were responsible for both murders and denying a feud between the UVF and LVF[2].

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Belfast murder victim had been ‘stood down’ as UVF chief, by David Sharrock, Guardian, 30 October 1996

[2] UVF challenged to deny role in loyalist’s shooting, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 30 November 1997

07-Dec-96

Peter (P.J.) Judge

41

M

U

Civilian

IRA

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Major drugs dealer in Dublin shot dead as sat in his car outside of a public house on Finglas Road. Mr Judge is believed to have been killed by the IRA because of his involvement in drugs.[1]

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] No one has been charged in relation to 15 killings carried out by gangs involved in drugs or other crime since 1998, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 13 March 2000

03-Feb-97

Larry McCartan

79

M

C

Civilian

Unknown

Laurencetown

Co Down

An SDLP councillor on the Banbridge District Council. Mr McCartan suffered a heart attack while he and his wife were evacuated during a hoax bomb alert.[1]

[1] Councillor dies during bomb hoax, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 4 February 1997

12-Feb-97

Stephen Restorick

23

M

U

Army

IRA

Bessbrook

Co Armagh

Soldier shot in the back by a sniper while manning a vehicle checkpoint[1].

In March 1999, an IRA sniper team consisting of Michael Caraher, James McCardle, and Martin Mines, and a 41-year-old man were convicted of offences relating to the killing and other serious offences. Mr Caraher, who shot the gun, Mr McCardle, and Mr Mines were each given 20 years for conspiracy to murder and 20 years for arms possession. There was not enough evidence to try any of them for murder. A 58-year-old man was found not guilty of making a shed available to terrorists.[2] Mr Caraher received a total of 105 years for those and other convictions. Mr McCardle was sentenced to additional time for the Docklands bombing. The 41-year-old man was convicted of the murder of Lance Bombadier Restorick and a large number of other IRA crimes and given concurrent sentences totalling 435 years. The four were released after 16 months under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement.[3] In October 2000, after he had already been freed, the 41-year-old was cleared of the murder by the Court of Appeal because he was not pro

     

[1] ‘Life’ means 16 months in prison for IRA killer, by John Mullin, Guardian, 20 March 1999

[2] IRA terrorist laughs after being convicted of soldier's murder, by Conal Urquhart, Scotsman, 20 March 1999

[3] Short walk to freedom for the last of Maze inmates, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 27 July 2000

[4] Man cleared of murder on appeal, Irish Times, 6 October 2000

Bernard McGinn (41 in 1999); Michael Anthony Kearns (58 in 1999)

14-Mar-97

John Slane

44

M

C

Civilian

UDA

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot five times in the chest at close range in the kitchen of his home. Loyalist forces revealed that the UDA might be responsible for the killing, but it was a case of mistaken identity. It was believed that the UDA had planned to kill a man with INLA ties who lived in the same area, and the UDA accepted that Mr Slane was completely innocent.[1]

A UDA man in his 20s who was suspected of killing Mr Slane was hiding out in Belfast as of 1998, protected by other loyalists[2]. In February 1998, Gerry Adams accused the RUC of failing to co-operate on investigations of murders by loyalist groups. One example cited was that they refused to release the forensic history of the weapon used to kill Mr Slane.[3]

   

[1] UDA is blamed for murder of Catholic, by Carmel Robinson, Irish Times, 17 March 1997

[2] Suspect in Bates killing defies UDA, by Henry McDonald, Sunday Times, 6 July 1997; New breed of killers combine gun culture with drug culture, by John Cusack, Irish Times, 24 January 1998

[3] Adams contrasts delay in tackling loyalists with speedy moves for Sinn Féin indictment, by Mark Brennock, Irish Times, 18 February 1998

24-Mar-97

Rev. David Templeton

43

M

P

Civilian

UVF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Presbyterian minister who died of a heart attack six weeks after a punishment beating at his home on 7 February 1997. It was alleged that Rev. Templeton was a homosexual because he was caught with a gay pornographic video by customs officials at Aldergrove airport. The UVF was blamed for the attack, which was committed by three men wearing balaclavas and wielding baseball bats with spikes driven through them.[1]

[1] UVF blamed for attack which killed minister, Irish News, 13 November 1997

08-May-97

Robert Hamill

25

M

C

Civilian

Loyalists

Portadown

Co Armagh

Died 11 days after he was assaulted by loyalist mob of about 30 in Portadown while four RUC officers in a nearby Land Rover failed to intervene. Mr Hamill was knocked unconscious almost immediately, and never regained consciousness.[1] Hon. Peter Cory, a Canadian judge, is examining this case, along with five others, to determine if an independent inquiry is warranted[2]. In June 2000, a Coroner decided not to hold an inquest because of concern for the safety of witnesses. The following day, the Taoiseach called for an independent judicial inquiry into the killing.[3] In the internal investigation, the officer suspected of providing advice to the killer was suspended and then released from service, two officers were disciplined internally, and two other high-ranking officers were believed to be part of the investigation[4].

Six men were initially charged with the killing, but only one man, Marc Hobson (22), stood trial. He was acquitted of murder in March 1999 because the judge felt it was impossible to be satisfied of his guilt, but was convicted and jailed for committing an affray.[5] He served only 6 weeks in jail[6]. In April 2001, the new Police Ombudsman ordered the arrest of seven people, but they were all released the following day[7]. Evidence has emerged that an RUC officer gave one of the killers advice on how to dispose of evidence in a telephone call shortly following the murder. James and Andrea McKee pleaded guilty to perverting the course of justice by falsely claiming to have made the call to protect the officer. They were sentenced to 6 months’ imprisonment and 6 months suspended sentence, respectively.[8] In 2003, the DPP decided to prosecute the officer, his wife, and a 52-year-old man for perverting the course of justice by giving false information relating to the call.[9]

     

[1] Getting to the truth behind Hamill death, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 28 December 2002

[2] Getting to the truth behind Hamill death, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 28 December 2002

[3] Ahern calls for inquiry into Hamill murder, by Frank McNally, Irish Times, 9 June 2000

[4] Officers face rap for work in killing, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 18 June 2003

[5] Man acquitted of Portadown murder during loyalist mob attack, Irish Times, 26 March 1999

[6] A hair's length from despair, by Jim Dee, Boston Herald, 11 June 2000

[7] Hamill detainees freed on police bail, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 12 April 2001

[8] Getting to the truth behind the Hamill death, by Gerry Moriarty, Irish Times, 28 December 2002

[9] Former RUC man among three on Hamill charges, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 4 July 2003

Robert Atkinson (49), Eleanor Atkinson (49), Kenneth Hanvey (52)

09-May-97

Darren Bradshaw

24

M

P

RUC

INLA

Belfast city centre

Co Antrim

Off-duty RUC officer who was shot several times at close range by two gunmen in a crowded gay bar. INLA admitted the murder two days later.[1]

[1] INLA claims gay bar killing, Irish Times, 11 May 1997

12 May 97

Sean Brown

61

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Randalstown

Co Antrim

GAA Manager shot by the LVF early in the morning on the day in which Darren Bradshaw was buried. Brown was abducted from Bellaghy, where he was locking up the GAA club after a meeting, and taken 10 miles to Co Antrim, where Bradshaw was buried. Police blamed the LVF for the killing.[1] The murder weapon used was the same gun used to kill John McColgan in January 1998[2]. The Irish News reported that Mark Fulton was implicated in the killing[3].

[1] Horror at cold-blooded murder of GAA official, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 14 May 1997

[2] Gun victim’s wife lodges complaint against RUC, by Martin Anderson, Irish News, 27 March 1999

[3] Fulton linked to 12 sectarian killings, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 11 June 2002

01-Jun-97

Gregory Taylor

41

M

P

RUC

Loyalists

Ballymoney

Co Antrim

Off-duty RUC man who left a bar at 1:15 a.m., then was pursued by a group of 12-15 men and kicked to death. The mob was supposedly Loyalists angry at the RUC for re-routing an Apprentice Boys parade through nearby Dunloy two weeks earlier.[1]

Eight men were accused of the murder. Two men, Leslie Henry (31) and Alistair Stevenson (31), were convicted of the murder and sentenced to life imprisonment. Two other men, Shane Brown (25) and Trevor MacLaughlin (25), admitted manslaughter and were sentenced to four years in prison.[2] Four men were acquitted of murder; two of them were also cleared of causing an affray, while two, Jason Wilmont (20) and Daniel Stewart (33) were granted bail after pleading guilty to causing an affray[3]. The two men convicted of murder, who lost the appeal of their convictions in 1999, were released in 2000 under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement.[4]

     

[1] RUC arrests five loyalist bandsmen after killing, by Michael O’Toole, Irish News, 3 June 1997

[2] RUC man’s ‘killers should not be freed’, by Jonathan Turner, Irish News, 24 December 1998

[3] Four acquitted in constable case, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 8 December 1998

[4] Loyalist prisoners, by Eithne Donnellan, Irish Times, 29 July 2000

Mark McIntyre and Samuel Coulter were acquitted of murder and causing an affray

04-Jun-97

John Morris

26

M

C

INLA

An Garda Síochána

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Armed robber, member of INLA, who died when shot by gardai. He was shot in the head and chest, holding a cocked handgun that was not loaded.[1] Three men were later jailed for the robbery in which Morris was killed[2].

Gardai were required to testify at the inquest, but were granted anonymity in September 1998 by the Dublin City Coroner. This ruling was overturned in October 1999 by the High Court, which ruled that coroners do not have the power to make this decision. The Supreme Court then upheld the coroner’s decision in July 2000, ruling that gardai can give evidence behind screens.[3] The inquest was begun on 27 June 2001, but Mr Morris’s parents withdrew because they claimed documents had been withheld from them. The jury returned a finding on 28 June 2001 that Mr Morris was fatally injured by a single bullet wound to the head and died the next day.[4]

   

[1] INLA warns gardai after shot robber dies, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 6 June 1997

[2] Three jailed for robbery in which man was shot dead, Irish Times, 11 March 1998

[3] Court decides gardai can give evidence behind screens, Irish Times, 18 July 2000

[4] Gardai say they shot gunman for aiming at them, by Judith Crosbie, Irish Times, 29 June 2001

11-Jun-97

Robert (Bobby) ‘Basher’ Bates

48

M

P

UVF

UDA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Mr Bates, a notorious member of the Shankill Butchers who was released from prison eight months earlier as a born again Christian, was shot at his workplace, the Ex-Prisoners Interpretive Centre, presumably in a revenge killing that was part of the UDA/UVF feud[1]. Mr Bates was reportedly killed in revenge for the murder of a Shankill road UDA man, James Moorhead, in 1977[2]. The person suspected of killing Mr Bates joined the LVF in late 1997 or early 1998[3]. The UVF attempted to kill the suspected murderer in a June 1999 gun attack[4].

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Loyalists fear ‘mad dog’ killer has joined LVF death squads, by Henry McDonald, Observer, 4 January 1998

[2] Loyalists ‘will avenge’ RUC men’s deaths, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 21 June 1997

[3] Loyalists fear ‘mad dog’ killer has joined LVF death squads, by Henry McDonald, Observer, 4 January 1998

[4] UVF ‘probably guilty’ of gun attack, by Paul McKillion, Irish News, 16 June 1999

16-Jun-97

Roland John Graham

34

M

P

RUC

IRA

Lurgan

Co Armagh

One of two RUC officers shot in the head at close range from behind while on the beat. The killing was claimed by the north Armagh brigade of the IRA.[1]

A 29-year-old man was charged with the killings nine days later, but was released on 3 October 1997 after the case collapsed amid controversy. The same man had previously served three and a half years of a life sentence for the 1993 murder of an off-duty officer, John Lyness, before being freed on appeal.[2] A 2002 newspaper story alleged that the killer is believed to be a former IRA operative who defected to the Real IRA sometime in 2002[3].

     

[1] RIRA threat 'at highest since Omagh', by Liam Clarke, Sunday Times, 4 August 2002

[2] Murder scene revisited, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 16 June 1998

[3] RIRA threat 'at highest since Omagh', by Liam Clarke, Sunday Times, 4 August 2002

Republican Colin Duffy (29 in 1998)

16-Jun-97

David Johnston

30

M

P

RUC

IRA

Lurgan

Co Armagh

RUC officer killed alongside Roland John Graham while on patrol[1]. (see above)

(see above)

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3564

07-Jul-97

Brian Morton

28

M

P

UDA

Self inflicted

South Belfast

Co Antrim

UDA member killed near his home while handling a pipe-bomb that prematurely exploded[1].

[1] UDA bomb accident victim is buried, Irish News, 12 July 1997

15-Jul-97

Bernadette Martin

18

F

C

Civilian

LVF

Aghalee

Co Antrim

Catholic woman shot dead by a man in a balaclava as she slept at her Protestant boyfriend’s house[1].

Trevor McKeown (39) was convicted of the murder in 1999. He appealed the conviction for the murder and for possession of the murder weapon, but lost the appeal. The murder weapon was allegedly also used in the murder of taxi driver Michael McGoldrick.[2]

   

[1] I cradled Bernadette in arms: boyfriend, Irish News, 17 March 1999

[2] Loyalist killer loses appeals, Belfast Telegraph, 20 September 2001

24-Jul-97

James Morgan

16

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Castlewellan

Co Down

Abducted, beaten to death with a hammer, burned, and found three days later in a water-filled pit on a farm. The pit contained animal carcasses, and it was revealed that a mechanical digger was used to pile more carcasses on top of his mutilated body.[1]

Norman James Coopey (27) was convicted of murdering James Morgan in January 1999. In March 1999, he applied for early release under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement.[2] He was released from prison on 28 July 2000 after 18 months in prison[3].

   

[1] Digger used in murder of schoolboy, by Louise McCall, Irish News, 4 August 1997

[2] Don’t free my boy’s killer, by Martin Anderson, Irish News, 2 March 1999

[3] Prisoner releases: Some smiled, others covered their heads, by John Mullin, Guardian, 29 July 2000

01-Aug-97

Stuart Hunter

24

M

P

Civilian

Loyalists

Larne

Co Antrim

Bludgeoned to death with an axe yards from his home, supposedly because he had reported an assault to the police three months earlier[1].

 

Loyalist feud?

David Joseph Campbell (21) and John Maloney (20) pleaded guilty to manslaughter in February 1999. They were jailed for five years and given one year probation on their release. The Belfast Crown Court said that the men were under the influence of a third man, whose name could not be released for legal reasons, who actually carried out the act. He was originally charged with the murder, but was released for lack of evidence.[2]

   

[1] Judge jails men who helped ‘evil killer’, Irish News, 25 March 1999

[2] Judge jails men who helped ‘evil killer’, Irish News, 25 March 1999

26-Sep-97

Brian O'Rawe

26

M

P

Civilian

Loyalists

Newtownards

Co Down

Mr O’Rawe’s body was found in the undergrowth of a Newtownards nature reserve, six weeks after he disappeared from his home[1]. The Deputy Coroner who presided over his inquest concluded it was not possible to determine the cause of death because his body was so badly decomposed. A 38-year-old man who confessed to the murder during informal conversations with the police said he attacked Mr O’Rawe, threw a hatchet at his back as he tried to run away, then strangled him with shoelaces before dumping his body in the nature reserve.[2]

A 38-year-old man was charged with the murders of Mr O’Rawe, William Elliott, Mark Sweeney, and William Paul, as well as conspiracy to murder and wound, possessing guns, robbery, theft and arson. He had made admissions during secretly recorded conversations with police about the murders, and confessed to some of the murders on being confronted with the taped admission. In October 2000, he was freed by Belfast Crown Court Lord Justice McCollum, who ruled that he would probably not get a fair trial because of inappropriate tactics used by the police in obtaining a confession.[3]

     

[1] Man faces trial over murders, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 12 January 2000

[2] Inquest told that man was informer, by Anne Madden, Irish News, 14 February 2001

[3] Murder accused freed despite confession, by Anne McClean, Irish News, 2 October 2000

Thomas Maginnis (38 in 2000)

25-Oct-97

Glenn Greer

28

M

P

Former UDA

UDA

Bangor

Co Down

Killed by booby-trap bomb attached to his car which exploded while he was driving along Drumhirk Drive. The bomb contained Powergel, which the UDA had recently acquired. Loyalist Frankie Curry later claimed he had committed the murder.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3568

08-Nov-97

Robert Kerr

54

M

P

Former UDA

LVF?

Newry

Co Down

Blown up by explosion on the Lorna Doon, a 36ft boat sitting on dry land in Newry. The death was reported as being an accident, but his family believes he was murdered.[137]

A 48-year-old man pleaded not guilty to conspiring with Mr Kerr to blow up the boat. At the trial, Mr Kerr’s wife said that Mr Kerr was living in fear of the LVF, and that they had been attacked and their home was burned down in the months leading to his death.[138]

     

[1] Loyalist killed in blast ‘feared’ LVF, Irish News, 12 October 2000

[2] Loyalist killed in blast ‘feared’ LVF, Irish News, 12 October 2000

James Alexander Gribben (48 in 2000)

09-Nov-97

Raymond McCord

22

M

P

Civilian

UVF

Newtownabbey

Co Antrim

Beaten to death and found in Ballyduff quarry. His father has a long history of confrontation with loyalist groups, including UDA punishment attacks and threats against his family by the UVF.[1] Mr McCord’s father claims that his son was killed on the orders of a senior UVF man who is a police informer and who has escaped justice repeatedly despite carrying out more than a dozen murders[2]. In 2003, the Ombudsman’s Office had compiled evidence on an RUC informant who has committed a string of murders but not been prosecuted. The Office was stopped from continuing the investigation, however, because of a lack of funding. Mr McCord snr called for a full inquiry into the role of the Special Branch in the matter.[3] In June 2003, a judge allowed Mr McCord snr the opportunity to pursue judicial review aimed at obtaining the material compiled in the Ombudsman’s investigation. Mr McCord expected proceedings to begin in the High Court in September 2003[4]. In July 2003, the alleged informer was reported to have left

[1] UDA blamed for quarry murder, by Steven McCaffrey, Irish News, 11 November 1997

[2] Coroner due to rule on inquest, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 9 May 2003

[3] Demand to Ervine from father of murdered man, by Stephen Dempster, IC Northern Ireland, 8 May 2003

[4] Progress in legal bid to find son’s killer, by David Gordon, Belfast Telegraph, 28 June 2003

[5] Murder bid UVF suspect ‘flees’, by David Gordon, Belfast Telegraph, 21 July 2003

05-Dec-97

James Gerard (Gerry) Devlin

36

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Glengormley

Co Antrim

Shot seven times at close range as he arrived alone to meet his brother at St Enda’s GAA club, which is the most targeted GAA premises in Northern Ireland. According to forensic evidence produced at the inquest, Mr Devlin was shot with the same Browning 9mm pistol later used to kill Philip Allen and Damien Trainor in Poyntzpass, and linked to three punishment shootings in the Portadown area and a gun attack in the home of a prison officer.[1]

[1] ‘Skulking’ LVF killers murdered easy target, Irish News, 15 October 1998

27-Dec-97

Billy Wright

37

M

P

LVF

INLA

Maze Prison

Co Down

Leader of the LVF shot inside Maze Prison, while sitting in a prison van, by INLA prisoners housed on the same H block. The carefully planned attack was led by Christopher ‘Crip’ McWilliams, who was serving a life sentence for the murder of a Belfast bar manager in 1991.[1]

Three INLA prisoners, Christopher ‘Crip’ McWilliams (39), John Glennon (32), and John Kennaway (35), were given life sentences for Wright’s murder in October 1998. They pleaded not guilty, but their counsel declined to outline their case. The IRSP and INLA were not party to the Good Friday Agreement, but the IRSP said they thought the three men would qualify for early release.[2] In October 2000, the three men were, in fact, released from jail after having served two years for the murder, as required by the terms of the Agreement[3].

   

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3571

[2] Lost Lives, no. 3571

[3] Billy Wright killers freed from jail, by John Mullin, Guardian, 21 October 2000

27-Dec-97

Seamus Dillon

45

M

C

Former IRA

LVF

Dungannon

Co Tyrone

Former republican life prisoner working as a doorman in the Glengannon Hotel. He was shot 12 hours after the INLA killing of LVF leader Billy Wright. He had severed his links to the republican movement after being released from prison in 1994.[1]

 

Revenge for Billy Wright

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3572

31-Dec-97

Edmund (Eddie) Treanor

31

M

C

Civilian

Loyalists

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Killed when two men sprayed the bar of the Clifton Tavern with bullets from an Uzi sub-machine gun, wounding 4 others as well. The LVF claimed the murder, but the RUC suspected UFF involvement as a known UFF member was seen in the getaway car.[1]

 

Revenge for Billy Wright?

[1] Murder victim’s family pleads for an end to the killing, by Niall Blaney, Irish News, 3 January 1998

11-Jan-98

Terry Enright

28

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Belfast city centre

Co Antrim

Community worker shot four times outside a club in Belfast where he was working as a doorman. A car parked outside the club, which served both sides of the community, and one gunman pointed a gun at the door while the other got out and fired over the top of the car. The LVF claimed the killing, saying it was in revenge for the killing of Billy Wright.[1]

 

Revenge for Billy Wright

A senior LVF paramilitary who was killed in 2002 was reportedly questioned about the murder but was never charged[2].

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3574

[2] Drug feud motive suspected in shooting of loyalist paramilitary, by Rosie Cowan, Guardian, 14 September 2002

Stephen Warnock, killed in September 2002

18-Jan-98

Fergal ‘Rick’ McCusker

28

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Maghera

Co Derry

Abducted and shot at close range as he walked home from a night out. His body dumped outside youth club in Maghera. The LVF claimed the killing as revenge for Wright.[1]

 

Revenge for Billy Wright

As of January 1999, no one had been charged with the murder[2].

   

[1] Fourth victim of LVF terror, by John Mullin, Guardian, 19 January 1998

[2] LVF victim’s American fiancée calls for justice, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 19 January 1999

19-Jan-98

Jim Guiney

38

M

P

UDA

INLA

Dunmurry

Co Antrim

Senior loyalist shot several times in his Dunmurry shop. The killing was supposedly timed to correspond with the arrival of Sinn Féin leaders Gerry Adams and Martin McGuinness at Downing Street for a meeting about Tony Blair’s blueprint for a political settlement to the conflict.[1]

[1] Tit-for-tat fear grips Ulster, by John Mullin, Guardian, 20 January 1998

19-Jan-98

Larry Brennan

52

M

C

Civilian

Loyalists

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Catholic taxi-driver shot four times in the chest by single loyalist gunman as he sat in his car on Ormeau Road in Belfast shortly before 7.30pm. Speculation was that he was either killed by the LVF in reprisal for the death of Billy Wright or by the UDA in retaliation for the killing of UDA member Jim Guiney.[1]

 

Revenge for Billy Wright?

A 26-year-old Belfast man was charged with the murder and possession of a firearm with intent to endanger life on 11 March 1998[2].

     

[1] Tit-for-tat fear grips Ulster, by John Mullin, Guardian, 20 January 1998

[2] Man charged on taxi-driver death, Irish Times, 12 March 1998

Harold Porter

21-Jan-98

Benedict Hughes

55

M

C

Civilian

Loyalists

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot by a single loyalist gunman as he left work. Witnesses heard five shots and found Mr Hughes slumped into the car. That same night, two other Catholics were wounded in shootings.[1]

[1] One dead, two hurt in night of carnage, by Peter McVerry, Irish Times, 22 January 1998

23-Jan-98

Liam Conway

39

M

C

Civilian

LVF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Catholic shot twice in the head by a single loyalist gunman as he sat in a mechanical digger as part of a team laying gas pipes on Protestant estate. No group admitted responsibility for the murder, but it was believed to have been carried out by loyalists.[1] Though the murder was never claimed, it was later attributed to the LVF[2].

 

Revenge for Billy Wright?

12 people have been arrested in connection with the murder but released due to lack of evidence[3].

   

[1] Catholic was ‘easy target for murder’, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 25 June 1999

[2] Tension at highest level in two years, Irish News, 7 December 2000

[3] Police appeal over getaway car, Irish News, 25 June 1999

24-Jan-98

John McColgan

33

M

C

Civilian

LVF

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Catholic taxi-driver shot and found dead at the side of the road at Hannahstown Hill. No group claimed responsibility but the LVF was thought to have been behind the attack.[1] Another taxi driver was shot in the head a few days later, but survived the attack[2]. The gun used to kill McColgan was the same weapon used in the murder of Sean Brown in May 1997[3].

 

Revenge for Billy Wright?

[1] Murder victim’s widow relives the last moment she spent with her husband, by Louise McCall, Irish News, 26 January 1998

[2] Taxi drivers plead for an end to the killings, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 26 January 1998

[3] Gun victim’s wife lodges complaint against RUC, by Martin Anderson, Irish News, 27 March 1999

09-Feb-98

Brendan ‘Bap’ Campbell

30

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot near a south Belfast restaurant as he made his way to his car. He was described by police sources as a major drug dealer, and the shooting was thought to be drugs-related.[1] Campbell had been targeted by DAAD previously. DAAD did not claim responsibility for the shooting, and an unidentified source informed the Irish News that he was killed because he put £15,000 on the head of a fellow drugs dealer.[2]

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] ‘Get dad out of coffin’ pleads shot man’s son, by Nevin Farrell, Irish News, 18 February 1998

[2] Campbell ‘shot by fellow dealer’, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 12 February 1998

10-Feb-98

Robert (Bobby) Dougan

38

M

P

UDA

IRA

Dunmurry

Co Antrim

Leading loyalist shot up to seven times outside a textiles factory, supposedly in direct retaliation for the killing of several Catholics, specifically John McColgan. Mr Dougan had survived two previous assassination attempts.[1] Sinn Féin was temporarily suspended from the Stormont talks following the murder[2].

Four men from west Belfast, ages 26, 25, 25, and 23[3], were charged in connection with the murder, but were released for lack of evidence[4].

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3582

[2] Coroner hears victim was loyalist, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 5 June 1999

[3] Solicitor protests at RUC ‘leaks’ on killing of loyalist, Irish Times, 17 February 1998

[4] Coroner hears victim was loyalist, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 5 June 1999

Samuel Baker, Sean Valente, William Groves, and Ronan Kennedy (26, 25, 25, and 23 in 1998) [4]

17-Feb-98

Kevin Conway

30

M

C

Civilian

IRA?

Aghalee

Co Antrim

Mr Conway's body was found in disused farmhouse with his hands bound behind his back and a gunshot wound to his head. RUC sources laid the blame on republicans, but said the motive was potentially criminal, rather than sectarian.[1] Later reports from the police confirmed that they believed local IRA elements were responsible, but did not know whether there was authorisation from the IRA leadership[2]. Potentially a punishment beating?

[1] Killing ‘down to republicans’, Irish News, 21 February 1998

[2] Unionists call for fresh SF expulsion, by William Graham, Irish News, 13 March 1998

03-Mar-98

Damian Trainor

25

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Poyntzpass

Co Armagh

Shot by a hail of bullets while having a drink in a bar with lifelong Protestant friend Philip Allen[1].

"LVF killers loses legal bid to get out of jail"  An application by Stephen McClean for a judicial review of a decision by the sentence review commissioners was dismissed in the high court [3].

Stephen McClean (31) and Noel McCready (34) were jailed for life in February 2000 for the murders. They were due to be released in July 2000 under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement, but lost their licences after being charged with attempted murder while out on parole. In June 2001, the pair lost high court appeals against their convictions.[2]

   

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3584

[2] Relatives delighted at ruling on killers, by Simon Doyle, Irish News, 29 June 2001

[3] Irish News, 16 May 2003

 

03-Mar-98

Philip Allen

34

M

P

Civilian

LVF

Poyntzpass

Co Armagh

Shot by a hail of bullets in a bar while having a drink with lifelong Catholic friend Damian Trainor[1]. (see above)

(see above)

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3585

15-Mar-98

David Oliver Keys

26

M

P

LVF

LVF

Maze Prison

Co Down

LVF man found strangled to death in his cell in the LVF wing of Maze prison. He was tortured and assaulted before being killed, and his body was hung from the window frame and wrists slit supposedly to feign suicide. He had been accused and was awaiting trial for the murders of Trainor and Allen.[1] After being arrested in the Poyntzpass killings, Mr Keys had taken police to a spot where clothes and weapons were discovered, so he was potentially murdered as an informer[2].

Two prisoners in the LVF wing in March 1998, ages 23 and 36, were tried for the murder, but the case collapsed when the key witness, former Maze prisoner David Patterson, refused to return to the witness box. The judge also cleared another prisoner who had pleaded not guilty to a charge of offering Mr Patterson £5,000 to withdraw his testimony.[3]

     

[1] Sheet used to strangle LVF man, Irish News, 28 March 2000

[2] Cell death of Poyntzpass accused: evidence heard, Irish News, 23 March 2000

[3] Protected witness ‘still waiting for new identity’, Irish News, 20 January 2001

Robin King and Ralph Phillips (23 and 36 in 2000), John Alexander Ferguson

27-Mar-98

Cyril Stewart

52

M

P

Former RUC

INLA

Armagh

Co Armagh

Retired part-time RUC reservist shot seven times by two gunmen outside a supermarket in Armagh in front of his wife[1].

In July 1999, Barry Paul Morgan (24) was convicted of killing Mr Stewart. A 35-year-old man was acquitted of conspiracy to murder and conspiracy to collect information.[2] In 1999, Barry Dinsmore (33) pled guilty to possession of weapons, including the gun used to kill Mr Stewart, membership in the INLA, and communicating information about two UDR soldiers, and was jailed for five years[3]. In February 2001, Neil Sheridan (25) was convicted of killing Mr Stewart and was sentenced to life in prison[4].

     

[1] No judgment yet in murder trial, Irish News, 24 January 2001

[2] Man convicted of killing policeman, Irish Times, 9 July 1999

[3] Killer gang ‘fled RUC trap’, Irish News, 23 September 1999

[4] Man gets life for murder, Irish Times, 27 February 2001

Anthony James McElkenny (35 in 1999)

07-Apr-98

Trevor Deeney

34

M

P

Former UVF

INLA

Derry

Co Derry

Derry loyalist shot up to six times outside his home as he was returning from work as a passenger in his wife’s car. INLA claimed responsibility for the murder, saying he was member of LVF. This was denied by his family and LVF, and LVF threatened reprisals.[1]

[1] Appeal as murder of loyalist is re-enacted, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 14 April 1998

17 Apr 98

Mark McNeill

32

M

C

Former INLA

INLA

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Taxi driver shot a number of times in the legs and chest while getting out of his car outside a taxi depot. Family members said he was a former INLA member killed because of an internal feud, but INLA denied responsibility.[1]

[1] Cabbie killed over grudge says family, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 20 April 1998

21-Apr-98

Adrian Lamph

29

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Portadown

Co Armagh

Council worker shot in the head and back at close range at a Craigavon borough council depot in Portadown by a gunman on a bicycle[1].

A 52-year-old woman was charged with the murder and possession of a firearm with intent to endanger life in 2001. She was freed on bail in June 2002 because of the length of time she had been in custody.[2] She has also been charged with a variety of other crimes, including possessing guns and explosives, membership of the LVF, and conspiring to cause explosions in the Irish Republic[3]. Ronald Wesley Allen (47), whose home was used in the murder, pleaded guilty to making property available to terrorists in May 1999. He received a two year term suspended for three years.[4]

     

[1] Catholic man shot dead, by Jonathan Turner and Steven McCaffrey, Irish News, 22 April 1998

[2] Murder charge mother of six freed on bail, Irish News, 18 June 2002

[3] Brother of dead LVF chief appears in court, Irish News, 14 June 2003

[4] Man freed over use of house in murder, Irish News, 15 May 1999

Muriel Gibson (52 in 2002)

25-Apr-98

Ciaran Heffron

22

M

C

Civilian

LVF

Crumlin

Co Antrim

Shot six times in the head while walking home after a night at the pub with friends. His body was found by a taxi driver in front of the local railway station.[1] No one claimed responsibility for the killing, but an investigating officer told the inquest that he was confident it was the work of the LVF because “it had familiar hallmarks to what had been LVF murders.” The murder weapon had been used in six other killings.[2]

Four men were arrested and questioned about the killing, two within hours of the attack and two within the next few days[3]. They were all released without charge, and at the time of the inquest in March 2000, no one had been charged in the murder[4].

   

[1] Two quizzed over Catholic’s murder, by Ian Graham, PA News, 26 April 1998

[2] LVF killed Catholic because it ‘was time’, by Alan Erwin, Irish News, 7 March 2000

[3] RUC arrests two more over killing of Catholic student, by Theresa Judge, Irish Times, 28 April 1998

[4] LVF killed Catholic because it ‘was time’, by Alan Erwin, Irish News, 7 March 2000

26-Apr-98

Thomas ‘Tucker’ Lockard

34

M

U

Civilian

CIRA?

near Kilcurry, Co Louth

Republic of Ireland

Body was found badly beaten, stabbed through the heart, and dumped in a ditch close to the Louth/south Armagh border. Gardai initially said the killing bore “the hallmarks of a paramilitary-style killing” and speculation linked the murder to the Continuity IRA.[1] His death has also been linked to DAAD[2]. Other speculation was that the killing was part of an internal drugs-gang feud or that Mr Lockard was killed by a hired paramilitary hitman. Mr Lockard was linked to the cross-border drugs trade and had been jailed in 1996 as part of an ecstasy smuggling ring.[3] One source also said he was a Garda informer who was discovered by a Border drug gang[4].

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] Man’s body found dumped near border, Irish News, 28 April 1998

[2] Drug war far from over say insiders, by Brendan Anderson, Irish News, 16 June 1998

[3] Gardai name murder victim, by Nevin Farrell, Irish News, 29 April 1998; No one has been charged in relation to 15 killings carried out by gangs involved in drugs or other crime since 1998, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 13 March 2000

[4] Shot loyalist likely victim of drugs feud, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 4 July 1998

01-May-98

Rónán MacLochlainn

28

M

C

RIRA

An Garda Síochána

Ashford, Co Wicklow

Republic of Ireland

Shot during Real IRA robbery of a security van by a GS emergency response unit. The first GS statement said there had been an exchange of gunfire, but it later changed the statement to say officers opened fire when the victim pointed a loaded gun at them. The other five men of the six-man armed gang were jailed for possession of weapons with intent to commit a robbery and assault with intent to rob.[1] Facts behind the killing are in dispute, and this has been further aggravated by the discrepancies in the police reports. Family members are pushing for an independent inquiry to determine whether law enforcement officials used excessive force in the operation.[2]

[1] Judge to sentence gang for fatal heist, by Diarmaid MacDermott, Irish News, 2 December 1998

[2] Report to the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Extra-Judicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions Concerning the Death of Rónán MacLochlainn, by British Irish RIGHTS WATCH, June 1998

01-Jun-98

Charles McConnell-Strain

28

M

P

None

UDA

Carrickfergus

Co. Antrim

Charles Strain was found dead two days after a savage punishment beating. Five men were questioned by police but no-one was charged.[1]

[1] Inquest into death of punishment victim, by Press Association, UTV News, 2 October 2003

03-Jul-98

William Henry ‘Wassy’ Paul

49

M

P

Former UVF

UVF

Bangor

Co Down

Gunned down outside his home as he returned from his daily trip to the newsagents for the morning papers. Mr Paul had left the Shankill Road three years before his murder after allegations that he was involved in dealing drugs. Police originally ruled out a sectarian motive in the murder, but the motive and details around the killing are confusing and controversial. Well-known loyalist Frankie Curry claimed he murdered Mr Paul over a personal feud, but speculation remained that it was a UVF killing.[1] However, Thomas Maginnis confessed to the murder during informal ‘conversations’ with police. In September 2002, the Police Ombudsman’s office admitted it was investigating allegations that police had been given warning the night before the murder. Mr Paul’s family claims that police were told the names of the two gunmen and the registration of their car, and seized clothing and a spent bullet casing within 24 hours of the shooting, but still failed to secure a conviction.[2]

A 38-year-old man was charged with the murders of Mr Paul, William Elliott, Brian O’Rawe, and Mark Sweeney, as well as conspiracy to murder and wound, possessing guns, robbery, theft and arson. He had made admissions during secretly recorded conversations with police about the murders, and confessed to some of the murders on being confronted with the taped admission. In October 2000, however, he was freed by Belfast Crown Court Lord Justice McCollum, who ruled that he would probably not get a fair trial because of inappropriate tactics used by the police in obtaining a confession.[3] A 54-year-old was charged in 1998 with withholding information about a car alleged to have been used in the murder[4].

     

[1] Murdered man left Shankill over threat, by Martin Anderson, Irish News, 4 July 1998

[2] Probe into evidence about murder claim, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 13 September 2002

[3] Murder accused freed despite confession, by Anne McClean, Irish News, 2 October 2000

[4] Murder ‘by UVF’ alleges counsel, Irish News, 3 December 1998

Thomas Maginnis, John James McCormick (54 in 1998)

12-Jul-98

Richard Quinn

11

M

C

Civilian

UVF

Ballymoney

Co Antrim

Eldest of three children killed in loyalist petrol bomb arson attack on their house during a week of heightened tension caused by Drumcree. The boys, their mother and brother had moved into the house less than a week before the attack. Though firefighters arrived within seven minutes of the alarm being raised, the boys were probably already dead when they arrived.[1] Five Catholic families who lived on the same predominantly Protestant estate supposedly received death threats from the UVF in the days leading up to the attack[2]. The boys’ uncle, Colum Quinn, allegedly had a feud with members of the UVF[3].

Garfield Gilmour (25 in 2000) was originally convicted of murder in the attack, but was cleared on appeal in June 2000. The judges substituted a conviction of manslaughter because Mr Gilmour drove other men to the scene, even though he had no knowledge of the intended attack until the last minute. He was denied leave to appeal to the House of Lords, but the court of appeal certified that a point of law of general public importance was raised in the case.[4] Mr Gilmour admitted driving three UVF men to the home[5].

     

[1] Sickening murders that shocked world, by John Manley, Irish News, 30 October 1999

[2] Catholics ‘targeted’ on Quinn estate, Irish News, 15 September 1999

[3] UVF killed the Quinn boys says accused, Irish News, 14 September 1999

[4] ‘Key legal question’ raised by Quinn trial, Irish News, 1 July 2000

[5] Driver knew of UVF’s evil intent, Irish News, 30 October 1999

The three UVF men named by Mr Gilmour are Johnny McKay, Raymond Parke, and Ivan Parke.

12-Jul-98

Mark Quinn

10

M

C

Civilian

UVF

Ballymoney

Co Antrim

(see above)

 

(see above)

     

12-Jul-98

Jason Quinn

9

M

C

Civilian

UVF

Ballymoney

Co Antrim

(see above)

 

(see above)

     

18-Jul-98

Andrew Kearney

33

M

C

Civilian

IRA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Bled to death after being shot in both legs during a punishment attack outside his flat. Mr Kearney was left to bleed to death in the lift or stairwell. Attackers ripped out the telephone line and jammed the lift, preventing Mr Kearney’s girlfriend from immediately getting help.[1] Mr Kearney’s mother said those responsible were not Sinn Féin or the IRA, but rogue elements within the republican movement who attacked Mr Kearney because of a personal feud with a north Belfast republican[2]. Mr Kearney had a reputation for getting into fights. Two weeks prior to the attack, he had a fight with an ex-IRA man, who was reported as being a previous IRA commander in Ardoyne who had been ‘stood down’ a year earlier.[3]

Two men were arrested on 27 July 1998[4], but as of 7 January 1999, no one had been charged with the killing[5].

   

[1] Mother pledges to ‘hound’ son’s killers, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 7 January 1999

[2] A mother’s fight against beatings, by Jonathan Turner, Irish News, 19 July 1999

[3] Ardoyne man key figure in Kearney murder, Irish News, 27 July 1998

[4] Two arrested over Kearney killing, Irish News, 28 July 1998

[5] Mother pledges to ‘hound’ son’s killers, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 7 January 1999

15-Aug-98

James Barker

12

M

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

Killed in 500 lb car bomb explosion at 3:10 p.m. on Market Street. A warning was given at 2:30 p.m., but named a different location. 28 people were immediately killed in the blast, one died of injuries three weeks later, and 200 people were wounded.[1]

 

Omagh bombing

Although more than 80 people have been arrested in relation to the bombing, only one person has been convicted. Colm Murphy was sentenced in January 2001 to fourteen years for conspiracy to cause an explosion. The families of the victims have also begun a £10 million civil case against five suspects.[2] In December 2001, a report was released by the Police Ombudsman’s office that reviewed the investigation of the bombing. The report suggested that the RUC failed to act on warnings before the bombing and criticized the investigation of the incident and the failure to bring the perpetrators to justice. This resulted in a major dispute between the former PSNI Chief Constable and the Ombudsman.[3] In April 2003, the Deputy Chief Constable of the Merseyside force, who was reviewing the investigation at the request of the Policing Board, claimed the issues highlighted by the Ombudsman’s report were being addressed[4].

   

[1] Lost Lives, nos. 3598-3625

[2] Omagh bombers will be caught, says report, by Dan Keenan, Irish Times, 4 April 2003

[3] Delight at the vindication of Omagh report, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 24 January 2003

[4] Omagh bombers will be caught, says report, by Dan Keenan, Irish Times, 4 April 2003

15-Aug-98

Fernando Blasco Baselga

12

M

U

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Geraldine Breslin

43

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Deborah Anne Cartwright

20

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Gareth Conway

18

M

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Breda Devine (age 20 months)

###

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Oran Doherty

8

M

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Aidan Gallagher

21

M

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Esther Gibson

36

F

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Mary Grimes

66

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Olive Hawkes

60

F

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Julia Hughes

21

F

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Brenda Logue

17

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Ann McCombe

48

F

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Brian McCrory

54

M

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Samantha McFarland

17

F

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Sean McLaughlin

12

M

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Jolene Marlow

17

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Avril Monaghan – pregnant with twins

30

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Maura Monaghan (age 18 months)

 

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Alan Radford

16

M

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Rocio Abad Ramos

23

F

U

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Elizabeth Rush

57

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Veda Short

56

F

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Philomena Skelton

49

F

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Bryan White

27

M

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Frederick White

60

M

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

15-Aug-98

Lorraine Wilson

15

F

P

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

(see above)

 

Omagh bombing

 

05-Sep-98

Sean McGrath

61

M

C

Civilian

RIRA

Omagh

Co Tyrone

Died of injuries from Omagh bombing[1].

 

Omagh bombing

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3627

25-Sep-98

Billy Giles

42

M

P

UVF

Self inflicted

East Belfast

Co Antrim

Hung himself after his release from prison, having served 15 years for UVF killing of Catholic workmate and friend Michael Fay[1].

[1] Killer’s remorse at Catholic death, by Brendan Anderson, Irish News, 27 February 1999

06-Oct-98

Frank O’Reilly

30

M

C

RUC

LVF

Portadown

Co Armagh

An RUC constable who died a month after being critically injured in a loyalist bomb blast attack during the Drumcree protest in Portadown on 5 September 1998. The Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility for the killing.[1]

Two men were arrested and a number of weapons were seized in an investigation linked to the murder of Mr O’Reilly[2]. In February 1999, the police revealed that the prime suspect in the case, who they had twice questioned and released without charge, had fled the North and was hiding in the Republic[3].

   

[1] RUC man’s killers branded ‘worthless cowards’, by Nevin Farrell, Irish News, 7 October 1998

[2] Two men held after weapons are found, Irish News, 20 October 1998

[3] Drumcree murder suspect hiding in republic, by Vincent Kearney, Irish Times, 28 February 1999

31-Oct-98

Brian Service

35

M

C

Civilian

LVF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot five times in the head and back in the Alliance Avenue area on the fringes of Ardoyne in North Belfast as he walked home from visiting his brother. The dissident group Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility for the shooting and warned there would be more, saying they were carrying out the attacks to register their opposition to the Good Friday Agreement.[1] An Irish Times reporter pins the killing on one of two LVF brothers from Ballysillan[2].

[1] New group threatens campaign of killing, by Michael O’Toole, Irish News, 3 November 1998

[2] Haemorrhage from within, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 16 December 2000

21-Nov-98

Gerard Moran

35

M

U

Civilian

IRA

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Petty criminal and small-time drug dealer shot by a lone gunman while working as a take-away delivery man[1]. Authorities are pinning responsibility on the IRA because Mr Moran was involved in a dispute with local IRA members[2].

[1] Paramilitaries may have killed Dublin criminal, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 5 December 1998

[2] Drug dealers ‘fair game’ to Provos, by Valerie Robinson, Irish News, 17 July 2000

27-Jan-99

Eamonn Collins

45

M

C

Former IRA

IRA

Newry

Co Down

Battered to death and stabbed repeatedly close to his home in Newry. He had been a member of the IRA, but later became a vocal critic. He at one time agreed to testify against former associates, but then refused to testify and disowned his prior statements.[1] Blood from a person other than Mr Collins was found on the scene, and police were using DNA testing to identify that person, believed to be a well-known IRA hitman who was living in the Republic as of April 2001[2]. Mr Collins’s widow said she believed ‘thuggish republican elements’, not the Armagh IRA, were responsible for his death[3].

On 13 April 1999, four men were arrested and six cars were removed for examination in dawn swoops on homes in south Armagh. The men were thought to be held in connection with the investigation into Mr Collins’s murder.[4]

   

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3631

[2] Police hold DNA clue to Collins’s killer, by Liam Clarke, Sunday Times, 23 April 2001

[3] Collins not murdered by IRA says widow, by Niall Blaney, Irish News, 10 February 1999

[4] SF angered as four held in Collins probe, by Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 14 April 1999

15-Mar-99

Rosemary Nelson

40

F

C

Civilian

LVF

Lurgan

Co Armagh

Solicitor blown up in loyalist booby-trap bomb placed beneath her car. The device exploded as she was driving away from her home in Lurgan. Before her death, Ms Nelson had complained about death threats against her by members of the security forces. Family members and NGOs have alleged that there may have been collusion in her death. The Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility for the killing.[1] Her case is one of the six being investigated by Hon. Peter Cory, a Canadian judge.

 

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3632

17-Mar-99

Frankie Curry

46

M

P

RHC

UVF

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot at least six times, including three times in the head while he was on the ground, as he walked through a park to visit his mother. The killing was part of an LVF/UVF feud. The RUC had warned him twice in the previous year of death threats.[1] Mr Curry appeared to be affiliated with a range of loyalist paramilitary organisations throughout the years, including the Red Hand Commando, the UDA, and possibly the UVF, the LVF, and the Red Hand Defenders[2].

 

Loyalist feud

As of December 1999, four men had been arrested in connection with the murder, but none of them had been charged[3].

   

[1] Loyalist killer warned by RUC, by Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 2 December 1999

[2] Lost Lives, no. 3633

[3] Loyalist killer warned by RUC, by Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 2 December 1999

09-May-99

Brendan ‘Speedy’ Fegan

24

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD?

Newry

Co Down

Shot repeatedly in the head by two masked gunmen in a Newry bar. Although his last words were reportedly, “It’s the Provies, it’s the Provies,” it is speculated that it was a drugs-related killing. Mr Fegan was a well-known drugs dealer whose life had been threatened before.[1] Newspapers report he was killed by the IRA/DAAD, though they vigorously deny the allegations[2]. One source alleged that Mr Fegan was suspected of being a police informer in the Republic and in Northern Ireland[3].

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] Sources deny Provos gunned down Speedy, by Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 11 May 1999

[2] 13 victims of the IRA’s policing drive, by Maeve Connolly, Irish News, 23 February 2002

[3] Flanagan says IRA suspected of killing dealer, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 14 June 2000

05-Jun-99

Elizabeth O’Neill

59

F

P

Civilian

LVF

Portadown

Co Armagh

Protestant married to a Catholic, living on Protestant estate in Portadown. A brick was thrown through a window into her living room, followed by a pipe bomb; the bomb exploded as she attempted to remove it.[1]

Philip Joseph Blaney (37), a former Special Branch agent, was found guilty of manslaughter, causing an explosion, possession of a pipe bomb, and possession of a firearm in January 2003. At his trial, Mr Blaney was said to be part of a four-man team of loyalists that had attacked two houses in the estate because of mixed relationships.[2] Mr Blaney did not throw the bomb at Mrs O’Neill’s house, as he was in charge of throwing the brick into the other house, so he was not charged with murder[3]. In July 2003, a 34-year-old man was awaiting trial on a total of 64 charges, including aiding and abetting the murder of Mrs O’Neill, a number of attempted murders, possession of guns and explosives, supplying Class A and B drugs, and belonging to and directing the activities of the LVF[4].

     

[1] Fulton in court on terror charges, UTV, 13 June 2003

[2] Relief as mother’s killer is convicted, by Simon Doyle, Irish News, 10 January 2003

[3] Court told loyalist gang killed Portadown woman, Irish News, 11 June 2002

[4] Bail situation is astonishing, Irish News, 23 July 2003

William James Fulton (34 in 2003)

13-Jun-99

Paul ‘Bull’ Downey

37

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD?

Belleeks

Co Armagh

Shot in the head after being abducted from the car park of a hotel. Mr Downey’s body, stripped to his underwear, was discovered by a farmer at a south Armagh roadside. Mr Downey was a known drugs dealer, and the killing was believed to be drugs related.[1]

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Unionists pin drug dealer’s murder on IRA, by John Manley, Irish News, 15 June 1999

29-Jul-99

Charles Bennett

22

M

C

IRA?

IRA

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Disappeared 25 July 1999 and was found four days later on waste ground near a GAA pitch with his hands tied behind his back, his face covered, and shot in head and neck at close range. Private security sources say they believe the IRA was responsible because Mr Bennett had stolen a weapon from the IRA.[1] Another source said he was killed for allegedly passing information to the RUC[2].

A 45-year-old man was originally charged with the murder, but the murder charge was withdrawn in December 1999[3].

     

[1] Lost Lives, no. 3637

[2] Terrorists still killing despite agreement, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 1 August 2001

[3] Bennett accused released, Irish News, 23 December 1999

Thomas Allsop (45 in 1999)

06-Oct-99

Patrick Campbell

22

M

C

INLA

Unknown

Walkinstown, Dublin

Republic of Ireland

INLA man beaten and stabbed in a battle between INLA and a Dublin crime gang after users of an industrial estate turned to INLA for protection. Mr Campbell died five days after the attack, probably from the knife wounds to his legs that hit arteries and caused a significant loss of blood.[1]

Daniel Finnegan (20) was charged with the murder, but the prosecution dropped the charge against him in July 2001, after the trial had begun, because it was discovered that he could not have caused the injuries from which Mr Campbell died. Mr Finnegan pleaded guilty to the second charge against him, engaging in a violent disorder.[2] Declan Duffy and Patrick O’Toole (27 and 23 in 2001) pleaded guilty to possession of a shotgun and to falsely imprisoning four men against their will during the confrontation and were given nine years and seven years in jail, respectively[3].

   

[1] Prosecution drops charges, Irish News, 27 July 2001

[2] Prosecution drops charges, Irish News, 27 July 2001

[3] Jail terms for two involved in INLA clash, by Diarmaid MacDermott, Irish News, 16 January 2001

01-Jan-00

Denver Smith

35

M

P

Loyalist?

Loyalists?

Antrim

Co Antrim

PUP member attacked in an open area of grassland on Stiles Estate in Antrim. Mr Smith was found battered to death with severe head wounds.[1] Mr Smith’s wife claimed the murder was carried out by ‘druggies’, denying that he was a member of a loyalist gang involved in a fight with drug dealers[2]. In December 2001, the Irish News reported that Ciaran Cummings was killed in retaliation for the murder of Mr Smith[3].

In October 2002, ten men, facing charges ranging from manslaughter and criminal damages to causing affray and assisting offenders, were sentenced in relation to the murder and an attack on a house in the estate. The men faced charges ranging from manslaughter and criminal damage to causing affray and assisting offenders, and were given jail sentences of up to seven years. Police were still investigating the actual murder in December 2002.[4]

   

[1] Police in fresh murder appeal, by Brian Campbell, Irish News, 31 December 2002

[2] Wife blames ‘druggies’ for PUP man’s murder, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 3 January 2000

[3] Murder 'was work of UVF renegades', by Sharon O'Neill, Irish News, 10 December 2001

[4] Police in fresh murder appeal, by Brian Campbell, Irish News, 31 December 2002

10-Jan-00

Richard Jameson

46

M

P

UVF

LVF

Portadown

Co Armagh

UVF leader shot in the head and chest by a lone gunman while sitting in his car outside his home in Portadown[1]. Thought to be retaliation for the attack on the Portadown Football Social Club on 27 December 1999, in which 12 people were injured, some of them LVF prisoners on Christmas parole. That attack has been attributed to the UVF as part of the LVF/UVF feud, and it has been said that Mr Jameson ordered the attack.[2]

 

Loyalist feud

A number of men were arrested within 24 hours of the killing[3]. An Irish Times reporter claimed the killing was committed by a young LVF man from Dungannon[4]. On 28 January 2000, a 37-year-old was charged with possessing the gun used to murder Mr Jameson[5].

     

[1] UVF chief shot dead by rival loyalist gang, by Valerie Robinson, Irish News, 11 January 2000

[2] Loyalist murder suspects held, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 12 January 2000

[3] Thousands at funeral of UVF man, by Jonathan Turner, Irish News, 14 January 2000

[4] Haemorrhage from within, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 16 December 2000

[5] Second man charged over Jameson murder, Irish News, 29 January 2000

Robert Samuel Scott (37 in 2000)

19-Feb-00

David McIlwaine

18

M

P

Civilian

UVF

Tandagree

Co Armagh

18-year-old found murdered and mutilated by the side of the road outside Tandagree, together with Andrew Robb. Both he and Mr Robb had been stabbed, suffering severe injuries. The killings were thought to be a retaliation attack by the UVF on the LVF for the death of Richard Jameson.[1]

Mr McIlwaine had no paramilitary connections[2].

'Father alleges PSNI cover-up over murder'  Belfast High Court heard a judicial review of the PSNI's refusal to allow Paul McIlwaine, David's father access to police files and witness statements on the case[6].

On the evening of the murder, Brown, Burcombe and Noel Dillon were drinking at Brown’s house in Sinton park when McIlwaine and Robb arrived looking for a party. (7)

The group soon began talking about the recent murder of Richard Jameson, described as ‘commander of the UVF in Portadown’. (8)

After Robb and McIlwaine allegedly made disparaging comments about Jameson, Brown was said to have threatened to ‘punch the head off’ of them.

In the early hours of the morning, the group then agreed to go out in Brown’s Peugeot car and get more drink and drugs. Whilst out, Brown parked the car next to a telephone box and all five got out.  Burcombe and McIlwaine walked down the road while Dillon and Brown took Robb ‘for a hiding’ after he had been ‘slabbering’ about Jameson. (10)

Burcombe said that he and McIlwaine were soon approached by Brown and Dillon. Brown then attacked McIlwaine who tried unsuccessfully to run away. Brown stamped on McIlwaine whilst he was on the ground and then Dillon pulled out a knife. Brown is then alleged to have said ‘kill the bastard – cut his throat’ and Burcombe says that he saw the pair crouching over McIlwaine making ‘sawing motions’. (11)

Brown, Dillon and Burcombe then returned to the car, where Dillon took off his jumper to wipe away the blood. Brown then said ‘I’m going to run over that bastard’s head’. (12

Brown then jumped out of the car with the knife and approached a bleeding McIlwaine. Burcombe says that he remembers a ‘terrible, gasping wheezing noise’. Brown then got back into the car and said ‘That gave me such a buzz. I forgot what it was like to kill’. (13)

Both of the victims died after suffering horrific injuries to their throats and stomachs. (14)

 

 

 

Loyalist feud

A 19-year-old man was charged with the murder, but the DPP dropped the charges in February 2001[3]. Another man was arrested for the murders in February 2002. At this time, the Irish News reported that a number of people had been arrested, and one had been charged before the charges were dropped, but no one had yet been convicted.[4] In April 2003, a top police officer agreed to meet with the McIlwaine family to discuss the investigation and the family’s concerns that no one had been convicted and no inquest had yet been held[5].

One of the men present at the murder, Mark Burcombe, 28, had come forward to give evidence against Steven Leslie Brown (also known as Steven Revels) and Noel Dillon Burcombe had originally faced murder charges himself but instead a deal was reached whereby in exchange for testifying against Brown (11), Burcombe was sentenced to two years and six months in jail for conspiracy to cause grievous bodily harm. (13) 

 

Noel Dillon killed himself in 2005.

 

In Brown’s trial, the prosecutor Gordon Kerr QC described the evidence against Brown as ‘compelling’. This included tyre marks at the murder scene matching the Peugeot car of Brown and Brown’s DNA was found on McIlwaine’s jacket. (11) Brown however said that he ‘definitely’ did not have anything to do with the killings and that Burcombe’s testimony was ‘lies’. (12)

Brown was given a minimum 30 year sentence for the double murders. (16) He announced that he was to appeal his conviction. (17)

However, it is also alleged that other individuals who were involved in the murder have escaped being brought to trial because they were working as police agents. This is principally because it was revealed that a building firm jointly owned by Portadown UVF leader Jameson had received over £11 million in government contracts for work on police stations and prisons. (15)

The families had also previously expressed concerns that a baseball cap known to belong to a senior UVF leader in Portadown (as the cap could only be purchased from a specialist store in California where he was known to have gone on holiday) was found near the murder scene. Witnesses near Brown’s house had also said that they had seen more than 6 men and as many as 3 cars. It is argued that Burcombe was told by the UVF to implicate only himself, Brown and Dillon in the murders. (14)  

 

     

[1] Two killed in tit-for-tat loyalist feud, by Michael Prescott, Sunday Times, 20 February 2000

[2] Savage reality of peace, Ulster-style, by John Mullin, Guardian, 26 February 2000

[3] Victims ‘not forgotten’, Irish News, 19 February 2001

[4] Arrest in Tandragee probe, Irish News, 1 March 2002

[5] Family to query murder inquiry, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 15 April 2003

[6] Northern Ireland.co.uk by Stephen Dempster 21 November 2000

(11) Accused said double killing gave him a buzz, court told, Ashleigh McDonald, Belfast Telegraph, 26/11/08

(12) Man accused of murdering teens say co-accused lied, Irish News, 3/2/09

(13) Witness jailed for ‘conspiracy’, BBC News, 27/6/08

(14) HET probes Haddock links to murder, Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 4/3/09

(15) Moment of relief for victim’s father, Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 4/3/09

(16) Son turns killer just like father, Ciaran McGuigan, Belfast Telegraph, 5/4/09

(17) Double killer appeals conviction, BBC News, 25/9/09

 

Steven Revels (19 in 2001)

19-Feb-00

Andrew Robb

19

M

P

LVF?

UVF

Tandagree

Co Armagh

19-year-old found murdered with David McIlwaine by the side of the road outside Tandagree[1] (see above). Mr Robb was allegedly an LVF ‘groupie’, known to the Tandagree UVF as such. His family, however, rejects the idea that he had any links to paramilitary or drug activity.[2]

Johnny Adair and several other local loyalist leaders attended his funeral[3].

On the evening of the murder, Brown, Burcombe and Noel Dillon were drinking at Brown’s house in Sinton park when McIlwaine and Robb arrived looking for a party. (6)

The group soon began talking about the recent murder of Richard Jameson, described as ‘commander of the UVF in Portadown’. (7) After Robb and McIlwaine allegedly made disparaging comments about Jameson, Brown was said to have threatened to ‘punch the head off’ of them.

In the early hours of the morning, the group then agreed to go out in Brown’s Peugeot car and get more drink and drugs. Whilst out, Brown parked the car next to a telephone box and all five got out.  Burcombe and McIlwaine walked down the road while Dillon and Brown took Robb ‘for a hiding’ after he had been ‘slabbering’ about Jameson. (8)

Burcombe said that he and McIlwaine were soon approached by Brown and Dillon. Brown then attacked McIlwaine who tried unsuccessfully to run away. Brown stamped on McIlwaine whilst he was on the ground and then Dillon pulled out a knife. Brown is then alleged to have said ‘kill the bastard – cut his throat’ and Burcombe says that he saw the pair crouching over McIlwaine making ‘sawing motions’. (9)

Brown, Dillon and Burcombe then returned to the car, where Dillon took off his jumper to wipe away the blood. Brown then said ‘I’m going to run over that bastard’s head’. (10)

Brown then jumped out of the car with the knife and approached a bleeding McIlwaine. Burcombe says that he remembers a ‘terrible, gasping wheezing noise’. Brown then got back into the car and said ‘That gave me such a buzz. I forgot what it was like to kill’. (11)

Both of the victims died after suffering horrific injuries to their throats and stomachs. (12)

 

 

 

Loyalist feud

A 19-year-old man was charged with the murder, but the DPP dropped the charges in February 2001[3]. Another man was arrested for the murders in February 2002. At this time, the Irish News reported that a number of people had been arrested, and one had been charged before the charges were dropped, but no one had yet been convicted.[4] In April 2003, a top police officer agreed to meet with the McIlwaine family to discuss the investigation and the family’s concerns that no one had been convicted and no inquest had yet been held[5].

One of the men present at the murder, Mark Burcombe, 28, had come forward to give evidence against Steven Leslie Brown (also known as Steven Revels) and Noel Dillon Burcombe had originally faced murder charges himself but instead a deal was reached whereby in exchange for testifying against Brown (11), Burcombe was sentenced to two years and six months in jail for conspiracy to cause grievous bodily harm. (13) 

 

Noel Dillon killed himself in 2005.

 

In Brown’s trial, the prosecutor Gordon Kerr QC described the evidence against Brown as ‘compelling’. This included tyre marks at the murder scene matching the Peugeot car of Brown and Brown’s DNA was found on McIlwaine’s jacket. (11) Brown however said that he ‘definitely’ did not have anything to do with the killings and that Burcombe’s testimony was ‘lies’. (12)

Brown was given a minimum 30 year sentence for the double murders. (16) He announced that he was to appeal his conviction. (17)

However, it is also alleged that other individuals who were involved in the murder have escaped being brought to trial because they were working as police agents. This is principally because it was revealed that a building firm jointly owned by Portadown UVF leader Jameson had received over £11 million in government contracts for work on police stations and prisons. (15)

The families had also previously expressed concerns that a baseball cap known to belong to a senior UVF leader in Portadown (as the cap could only be purchased from a specialist store in California where he was known to have gone on holiday) was found near the murder scene. Witnesses near Brown’s house had also said that they had seen more than 6 men and as many as 3 cars. It is argued that Burcombe was told by the UVF to implicate only himself, Brown and Dillon in the murders. (14)  

 

   

[1] Two killed in tit-for-tat loyalist feud, by Michael Prescott, Sunday Times, 20 February 2000

[2] Savage reality of peace, Ulster-style, by John Mullin, Guardian, 26 February 2000

[3] UFF boss attends funeral of youth, by Cara O’Doherty, Irish News, 22 February 2000

(11) Accused said double killing gave him a buzz, court told, Ashleigh McDonald, Belfast Telegraph, 26/11/08

(12) Man accused of murdering teens say co-accused lied, Irish News, 3/2/09

(13) Witness jailed for ‘conspiracy’, BBC News, 27/6/08

(14) HET probes Haddock links to murder, Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 4/3/09

(15) Moment of relief for victim’s father, Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 4/3/09

(16) Son turns killer just like father, Ciaran McGuigan, Belfast Telegraph, 5/4/09

(17) Double killer appeals conviction, BBC News, 25/9/09

 

26-Feb-00

Joseph Foran

38

M

U

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Heroin dealer shot by a single .38 bullet fired through the open window of his car as he sat with his girlfriend outside his home. The killing was believed to have been committed by a member of the IRA who came in after complaints about the damage Mr Foran and other drug dealers had done in the community.[1]

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] No one has been charged in relation to 15 killings carried out by gangs involved in drugs or other crime since 1998, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 13 March 2000

29-Apr-00

Patrick Neville

31

M

U

Civilian

INLA

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Found shot in a stairway in a block of flats near his home. His death was possibly in retaliation for the death of INLA member Patrick Campbell in October 1999.[1]

A man who was killed several months later was questioned about Mr Neville’s killing shortly before his own death[2]. In July 2001, Kevin McLaughlin (36) pleaded guilty to collecting information useful to an unlawful organisation (INLA) regarding the movements of Mr Neville between 1 January and 29 April 2000. He was the first person to be jailed under the new post-Omagh legislation, Section 8(1), of the Offences Against the State (Amendment) Act of 1998, and was sentenced to four years.[3]

     

[1] An Index of Deaths from the Conflict in Ireland, by Malcolm Sutton, CAIN web service, <http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/sutton/chron/2000.html>

[2] Gardai trawl underworld of Dundalk after two killings, by Clare Murphy, Irish Times, 26 August 2000

[3] Belfast man first jailed under new post-Omagh legislation, Irish News, 7 July 2002

Nicholas O’Hare, killed in August 2000

30-Apr-00

Thomas Byrne

41

M

U

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Minor drug dealer killed as he sat drinking with friends outside a pub by a lone gunman who walked up to him and shot him. Gardai knew that he had an argument with the man in command of the IRA in Dublin over two years before the killing. Byrne had reportedly offered to pay compensation for the wrong inflicted on the commander, but the offer was refused.[1] An IRA man from north inner Dublin was the prime suspect in the killing[2].

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Killings linked to gangland drug war, by Conor Keane, Irish News, 2 May 2000

[2] Flanagan says IRA suspected of killing dealer, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 14 June 2000

26-May-00

Martin ‘Chin’ Taylor

35

M

P

UVF

Loyalists

North Belfast

Co Antrim

UVF volunteer shot by two gunmen while working outside a house in the loyalist Ballysillan area. Mr Taylor’s death was part of the ongoing loyalist feud between the LVF and UVF.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Hundreds pay tribute to loyalist feud victim, by Jonathan Turner, Irish News, 1 June 2000

29-May-00

Edmund McCoy

28

M

C

Civilian

IRA

Dunmurry

Co Antrim

Well-known figure in the drugs scene shot in the head and stomach at Motte ‘n’ Bailey Bar, Dunmurry, on 28 May 2000. He died a day later. Mr McCoy was once suspected of shooting Johnny Adair, and had been threatened in the past by the IRA.[1] The IRA was blamed from the beginning, and several weeks later, the RUC continued to suspect the IRA was behind the attack[2].

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Shot man ‘suspect’ in Adair shooting, by Jonathan Turner and Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 30 May 2000

[2] IRA can’t be ruled out says Flanagan, Irish News, 14 June 2000

12-Jul-00

Andrew (Andy) Cairns

22

M

P

UVF

UDA

Larne

Co Antrim

UVF man surrounded by a crowd, punched and kicked, then shot during a UDA/UVF loyalist feud at an eleventh night bonfire in Larne[1].

"PSNI knows identity of LVF Bonfire night killer" Police knew the identity of an LVF member who allegedly shot a UVF man dead but did not have the evidence to prove it, an inquest heard[5].

 

Loyalist feud

Three men, ages 21, 27, and 18, were charged with the murder and a 25-year-old woman was charged with assisting the offenders and withholding information. The 21-year-old was allegedly a member of the UDP.[2] A 19-year-old man was charged with assisting the offenders by taking clothing and destroying it[3]. In October 2000, a 28-year-old man was charged with having explosives and a document of use to terrorists, and was believed to be the gunman in the killing[4].

     

[1] Bonfire murder accused is UDP member, Irish News, 19 July 2000

[2] Bonfire murder accused is UDP member, Irish News, 19 July 2000

[3] 11th killing: man charged, Irish News, 27 July 2000

[4] Bail refused for Larne man, Irish Times, 19 October 2000

[5] Belfast Telegraph by Claire Regan, 16 December 2003

Alan Murray, David Murray, and Ryan Robert Connor (21, 27, and 18 in 2000), Joslyn Magill (25 in 2000), Thomas Sean Paul O’Toole (19 in 2000), Gary Mervyn Robb (28 in 2000)

28-Jul-00

Stephen Connolly

26

M

U

Civilian

INLA?

Dundalk, Co Louth

Republic of Ireland

A Dundalk publican who was shot by a masked gunman as he sat in a parked car with his girlfriend. Mr Connolly was allegedly killed because he refused to pay a gang of criminals protection money. A masked gang of five men, all of whom allegedly had links to INLA, tried to abduct him in March 2000, and it is believed this gang was behind his murder. Gardai believe that Nicholas O’Hare was not the gunman in the attack, but Mr O’Hare’s death three weeks later might have been linked to Mr Connolly’s death.[1]

[1] Gardai trawl underworld of Dundalk after two killings, by Clare Murphy, Irish Times, 26 August 2000

19-Aug-00

Nicholas (Nicky) O’Hare

34

M

C

Former INLA

Republicans

Dundalk, Co Louth

Republic of Ireland

Shot at least eight times, including two shots in each eye, in the street in Dundalk, possibly as part of an INLA feud. It is believed that O’Hare murdered Dundalk publican Stephen Connolly three weeks earlier because he refused to pay protection money.[1] Gardai had arrested O’Hare in relation to the April 2000 murder of Patrick Neville, who died as part of a feud between a Dublin gang and INLA. They also suspect that his murder can be linked to the murder of INLA member Patrick Campbell in October 1999.[2] The Irish Times, however, reported that he was killed by the IRA for suspected involvement in crime[3].

[1] Murder suspect was shot twice in each eye, by Elaine Keogh, Irish Independent, 11 February 2003

[2] ‘Mad Nick’ O’Hare dies in hail of bullets, by Elaine Keogh, Irish Independent, 21 August 2000

[3] Gardai have open minds as to killers of ‘Shavo’ Hogan, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 17 July 2001

21-Aug-00

Jackie Coulter

48

M

P

UDA

UVF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

A prominent member of the UDA shot with Bobby Mahood while sitting in a stationary jeep on the Crumlin Road during the UDA/UVF feud which broke out the previous weekend on the Shankill Road. The UVF was blamed for the killings.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

In October 2000, two men were arrested and questioned by the police presumably in relation to the killings[2]. In January 2001, however, Mr Coulter’s daughter said no one had been convicted, despite the fact that the police knew who the killers were[3].

   

[1] Shot men linked to opposing factions, by Alan Erwin and Anne Madden, Irish News, 22 August 2000

[2] Two quizzed on loyalist feud deaths, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 17 October 2000

[3] Forgotten victims of the feud, by Nell McKnight, Irish News, 30 January 2001

21-Aug-00

Robert (Bobby or Robbie) Mahood

48

M

P

UVF

UVF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Brother of UVF leader Jackie Mahood, who survived an assassination attempt a month before Bobby’s death, killed with friend Jackie Coulter while sitting in a stationary jeep on the Crumlin Road[1] (see above). UVF sources reportedly said Mr Mahood’s death was an accident[2].

 

Loyalist feud

(see above)

   

[1] Shot men linked to opposing factions, by Alan Erwin and Anne Madden, Irish News, 22 August 2000

[2] Funeral of man killed by ‘mistake’, by Steven McCaffrey, Irish News, 25 August 2000

23-Aug-00

Samuel Rocket

21

M

P

None

UDA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot in front of his girlfriend and daughter while in their home in Lower Oldpark. The killing was in retaliation for the shootings of Jackie Coulter and Bobby Mahood two days earlier.[1] Less than a week later, his home was set on fire, allegedly by the UVF after they had moved Mr Rocket’s girlfriend out of the house[2]. At his inquest, a senior police officer told the court that Mr. Rockett was not a UVF man but had been an easy target for those involved in the feud.[3]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Feud victim is given paramilitary sendoff, Irish News, 28 August 2000

[2] Girl’s shooting may be linked to feud, by Gerry Moriarty and Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 29 August 2000[3] Loyalist feud victim was a 'completely innocent man', Irish News, 4 October 2003

29-Sep-00

Patrick Quinn

32

M

C

Civilian

IRA / DAAD

Magherafelt

Co Derry

Singled out and shot by two gunmen while having a drink in the Depot Bar. No one immediately claimed responsibility for the murder, but sources pointed to DAAD. Mr Quinn was a close associate of Brendan Campbell, who was killed by DAAD in February 1998.[1] The IRA reportedly used a new gun, with no ballistic tracing, in Mr Quinn’s killing[2].

 

Drugs-related killing

[1] Pub shooting victim is buried, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 3 October 2000

[2] Inspectors are expected to verify that IRA weapons remain unused, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 26 October 2000

13-Oct-00

Joseph O’Connor

26

M

C

RIRA

IRA

West Belfast

Co Antrim

RIRA man shot 10 times with a .38 revolver and 9mm pistol by two hooded men while sitting in a stationary car outside his mother’s home in Ballymurphy. Mr O’Connor’s brother-in-law, who was in the car at the time, knew the identity of the killers but refused to co-operate with the police for fear of his safety.[1] Immediately after the murder, two IRA men publicly announced that Mr O’Connor was killed by the IRA, then immediately were denounced by Sinn Féin and were targeted themselves[2]. Mr O’Connor’s widow blames the murder on the IRA, and an investigating officer stated in October 2002 that the police believe the IRA was responsible[3]. The IRA reportedly used a new gun with no ballistic ‘traces’ in Mr O’Connor’s killing[4]. In 2003, graffiti sprayed on a wall in Belfast indicated that Mr O’Connor was killed because he threatened to expose Stakeknife[5].

 

IRA on dissidents

[1] O’Connor murder: call for fresh police report, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 18 October 2002

[2] An Illusory Peace in Northern Ireland; Five Years After Good Friday Pact, Conflict Still Simmers Behind Calm Façade, by Glenn Frankel, Washington Post, 4 May 2003

[3] Police taken to task over murder of RIRA chief, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 17 October 2002

[4] Inspectors are expected to verify that IRA weapons remain unused, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 26 October 2000

[5] From feared IRA chief to assassination target, by Thomas Harding, Ted Oliver and Sean O'Neill, Daily Telegraph, 12 May 2003

28-Oct-00

David Greer

21

M

P

UDA

UVF

North Belfast

Co Antrim

UDA man shot once in the chest while walking along Mountcollyer Street, Tiger’s Bay. The killing was part of the loyalist feud.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Victim goes to grave with UFF flag, by Billy Foley, Irish News, 2 November 2000

31-Oct-00

Herbert (Bertie) Rice

63

M

P

UVF

UDA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Beaten with baseball bats, then shot in front of his wife at his home in Tiger’s Bay. The assault was part of the loyalist feud, and thought to be a reprisal for the killing of UDA member David Greer.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Man dies after ‘reprisal’ shooting, BBC News, 31 October 2000

31-Oct-00

Tommy English

40

M

P

UDA

UVF

Newtownabbey

Co Antrim

Shot three times in the chest by four masked UVF gunman as he lay on the sofa in his living room several hours after Bertie Rice was killed. The killing was in retaliation for the death of Bertie Rice as part of the ongoing loyalist feud.[1]

Tommy English had been a UDA leader.  His death was as a result of a feud with the rival UVF, in which 7 people died (3)

It is alleged that a four man UVF team went to English’s house to carry out the murder (Haddock, Higgins, Laffin and Wood). One member carried a sledgehammer, another a shotgun and Wood agreed to carry out the killing with a handgun. (7)

 

 

Loyalist feud

A number of people were questioned in the murder, but as of March 2003, no one had been charged[2].

Robert John Stewart, 35, and David Ian Stewart, 39, are given life sentences for aiding and abetting in the murder. (4) They had originally faced a murder charge, but after agreeing to give further information against other UVF members, this charge was reduced. (6) The arrests came as a result of Nuala O’Loan’s (Police Ombudsman) request for the Historical Enquiries Team to examine the case. (5)

As a result of the police statements of the Stewart brothers, Mark Haddock was charged with the murder of Tommy English.  It was also revealed that he had been working as a Special Branch agent for 12 years. (6) Three other members of the UVF have also appeared in court facing the same murder charges.  These included Samuel Higgins, 32, Philip Laffin, 31, Alex Wood, 32 (who allegedly fired the shots). In total 11 people were charged with various offences connected to the murder. (8)

 

   

[1] Wife of UDA boss injured in struggle, Irish News, 27 March 2003

[2] Wife of UDA boss injured in struggle, Irish News, 27 March 2003

(3) Haddock to face murder questions,  Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 7 Aug 2008

(4) Brothers jailed over English murder, UTV News, 26 June 2009

(5) Brothers are charged with feud murder of UDA boss, Chris Thornton, Belfast Telegraph, 8 Aug 2008

(6) English murder – 5 charged,  Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 22 Jan 2009

(7) Bail refused in UDA murder case,  BBC News, 26 March 2009

(8) Man arrested over English murder, BBC News, 28 April 2009

 

 

01-Nov-00

Mark Quail

26

M

P

UVF

UDA

Newtownabbey

Co Antrim

Shot at least eleven times in the head and chest in his home on the outskirts of Belfast as part of the loyalist feud[1]. A UDA member who became the new leader of the South East Antrim Brigade of the UDA in February 2000 was reportedly involved with the shooting[2].

 

Loyalist feud

Five men were questioned, but no one was ever charged with the murder[3].

   

[1] Loyalist killer was asked to stop after at least 11 shots, Irish News, 10 June 2003

[2] New UDA brigadier link to McColgan and Quail murders, by Stephen McGoldrick, Irelandclick.com, 28 February 2003

[3] Loyalist killer was asked to stop after at least 11 shots, Irish News, 10 June 2003

05-Dec-00

Trevor Kell

35

M

P

Civilian

IRA?

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Taxi driver shot once in the head in Ardoyne on Crumlin Road shortly after being lured by a bogus pick up call to a house. The IRA and the dissident RIRA and CIRA denied any connections to the murder.[1] Sinn Féin accused loyalists of committing the crime, but the RUC blamed republicans[2].

'Suspects were shot in the legs' Det. Chief Superintendent Brannigan told the inquest that Mr Kell's murder was a purely random sectarian murder.  Two arrests were made but, both men were released due to a lack of evidence.  Det. Chief Superintendent Brannigan confirmed that there were two punishment shootings subsequent to the murder[5]

A few days after being released, a 22-year-old republican who had been held for questioning about the murder was injured in a paramilitary-style attack, receiving shots in the wrists, ankles, and elbow, allegedly by the IRA[3]. In late December 2000, police stated that this man was an IRA prisoner who had been freed under the Good Friday Agreement shortly before the murder, and admitted that they believed he was involved in the killing[4].

   

[1] IRA shoots man held in Kell case, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 22 December 2000

[2] Freed IRA man linked to murder, Sunday Times, 24 December 2000

[3] IRA shoots man held in Kell case, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 22 December 2000

[4] Freed IRA man linked to murder, Sunday Times, 24 December 2000

[5] Irish News, 30 October 2003

06-Dec-00

Gary Moore

30

M

C

Civilian

UDA

Newtownabbey

Co Antrim

Builder shot four times in the head and body while working on building site in a loyalist housing estate in Monkstown, Newtownabbey, apparently in reprisal for the murder of Trevor Kell. Another Catholic, Paul Scullion, was seriously injured outside a taxi depot in Oldpark Road 15 minutes later.[1] One report connected the murder to associates of John Gregg, the UDA commander who was killed in February 2003[2].

[1] Funeral of loyalist gun attack victim, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 9 December 2000

[2] Retaliation seems inevitable, just a question of when, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 3 February 2003

17-Dec-00

James William Rockett

29

M

P

Loyalist (UDA?)

UDA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Body found shot with a single bullet wound to the back of his head on waste ground in Ballysillan. The victim had loyalist tattoos on his body and £2,000 cash in his pocket.[1] Shortly after the murder, police stated that they believed Mr Rockett was possibly a victim of a dispute unconnected to the loyalist feud. A senior UDP leader blamed drug dealers for the killing.[2]

 

Loyalist feud?

[1] ‘Loyalist link’ to Belfast murder, BBC News, 18 December 2000

[2] ‘Criminal’ element blamed for killing, by Billy Foley, Irish News, 19 December 2000

28-Dec-00

Ronald Hill

68

M

U

Civilian

IRA

Enniskillen

Co Fermanagh

Victim of 1987 Enniskillen bombing who went into a coma two days after he was injured in the bombing. Mr Hill died after spending 13 years in a coma.[1]

[1] Poppy day bombing victim dies, by Todd R. Nicholls, Irish News, 29 December 2000

06-Jan-01

George Legge

37

M

P

UDA

UDA / RHD

Carryduff

Co Down

 

George Legge’s body was found dumped at Carryduff. His throat had been cut, and he had multiple stab wounds. The nature of his death has been likened to the work of the Shankill Butchers gang in the 1970s. [1]

Legge was called to the Bunch of Grapes bar, owned by Jim Gray (dec). [1] Forensic evidence indicates that Legge was attacked and killed in the bar. [2]

Legge had fallen out of favour with other UFF leaders some months before his murder. [3]

Legge had been unofficially implicated in the murder of Ned McCreery, who was shot dead on 15 April 1992. Leonard McCreery, the victim’s brother, subsequently tried to kill Legge. [5]

 

 

 

 

 

Loyalist feud

Four men were arrested and questioned about the murder, but subsequently released without charge. [5]
 

The inquest took place in August 2006. [1]

 

 

   

[1] Loyalist murder ‘as barbaric as Shankill Butchers’. Irish News. 01.08.06

[2] UDA man’s murder was ‘barbaric and dreadful’. Irish News. 02.01.08

[3] Loyalist bar killing ‘horrific’. BBC News. 01.08.06

[4] A view North. UDA Drug cartel: a sordid History. Irish Echo. 17-23.01.01

[5] Men questioned about loyalist’s murder. BBC News. 05.12.01

 

09-Feb-01

Kieran Smyth

39

M

U

RIRA

IRA?

Curraha, Co Meath

Republic of Ireland

Found in a cattle pen in a field near Curraha, Co Meath, shot in head and beaten. Mr Smyth had allegedly been a close associate of RIRA who was involved in cigarette smuggling and money laundering. The murder might also have been drugs related. Mr Smyth had been questioned in relation to the murder of Newry businessman Richard McFerran in Dundalk in 1999 and three specialist Garda units had been investigating his activities, but he had no criminal record.[1]

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] Murdered man ‘went bravely’ says dad, by Simon Doyle, Irish News, 16 February 2001

27-Feb-01

Bobby McGuigan

36

M

C

Civilian

IRA?

Lurgan

Co Armagh

Shot a number of times by two masked gunmen as he sat alone in his parked car. Mr McGuigan had a criminal record and criminal links, and was reportedly the victim of a punishment beating in January 1999.[1] The Irish Times listed him among a group of men who had been killed by the IRA for alleged involvement in drugs dealing or criminal activity[2].

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] Shooting was not sectarian says RUC, by Aeneas Bonner, Irish News, 1 March 2001

[2] Main terrorist groups still recruit and train, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 3 July 2001

13-Mar-01

Adrian Porter

34

M

P

LVF

UVF

Conlig

Co Down

LVF member on bail for drugs charges who died several hours after two gunmen opened fire with an automatic rifle and a handgun on a house in Conlig. A 21-year-old was also shot but survived. Six months before his murder, Porter was granted bail in the High Court on a charge of possessing 20 kilos of cannabis with intent to supply. The 21-year-old had received a death threat made shortly before the shooting.[1] One source indicated that Jim Johnston, an RHC leader who was killed in May 2003, was a suspect in the killing[2].#

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Killing linked to loyalist warning, by Billy Foley, Irish News, 15 March 2001

[2] Murder tarnishes image of Ulster's smart Gold Coast, by David Lister, The Times, 10 May 2003

03-Apr-01

Trevor Lowry

49

M

P

Civilian

UDA

Glengormley

Co Antrim

Protestant beaten so badly, especially in the face and head, that he died two days later. The attack took place in Glengormley, a nationalist area, where he may have been mistaken for a Catholic. Three men in a white Ford Escort, MXI 4115, tried to abduct another man leaving a GAA club shortly afterwards.[1]

Two men, ages 44 and 18, were charged with the murder. Their cases are, according to prosecuting QC Patrick Lynch, inextricably linked together. In June 2003, two weeks into the trial, the defence team for the accused withdrew from the case for ‘professional’ reasons. The trial was to be adjourned at least until September 2003.[2]

Harry  Speers (44) and Ronald Craig (19) were both given life sentences for murder by Belfast Crown Court [3]

 

Speers was an UDA activist and past Orange Order district master. The Orange Order stated that they will expel him from the group if he is still a member [4]

     

[1] Murdered Protestant attacked ‘by mistake’, by Anne Madden, Irish News, 4 April 2001

[2] Murder trial may have to be aborted, Belfast Telegraph, 2 June 2003

[3] Convictions bring relief and hope to area, by Marie McCrory, Irish News, 24/03/2004

 

[4] Killer was an Orange district master, By David Gordon, Belfast Telegraph, 24/03.2003

 

James Harry Speers and Ronald Craig (44 and 18 in 2003)

11-Apr-01

Grahame Marks

37

M

P

UVF

LVF / RHD

Tandagree

Co Armagh

Shot several times at his home on Tullyhue Estate in Tandragee by a single gunman using an automatic weapon. A silver Audi A4 that had been stolen in December was used in the attack. The killing was believed to have been part of the loyalist feud. Mr Marks had been questioned by the police the previous year in connection with the murders of David McIlwaine and Andrew Robb.[1] The gun was the same weapon used to kill Martin O’Hagan in September 2001[2].

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Inquiry into murder continues, BBC News, 19 April 2001

[2] How the UDA kept its peace, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 13 October 2001

21-Apr-01

Christopher ‘Cricky’ O’Kane

37

M

C

Former INLA

IRA / DAAD?

Tullyally

Co Derry

Derry area drugs baron shot four times in the stomach, probably by the IRA. Mr O’Kane was formerly involved in INLA, but it was speculated that he had become an RUC infomer. Loyalist groups (UVF, UDA) had either threatened or attempted to kill him.[1] Sutton says a non-specific Republican group was responsible for the death[2].

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] Drugs boss had ‘many enemies’, by Anne Madden, Irish News, 23 April 2001

[2] An Index of Deaths from the Conflict in Ireland, by Malcolm Sutton, CAIN web service, <http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/sutton/chron/1999.html>

01-May-01 Mark 'Mousey' Robinson 22 M C   IRA Moss Park, Derry  

Robinson was beaten with scaffolding poles and stabbed with a dagger [1]

This followed an alleged row with a republican in a bar.  He was also a victim of paramilitary style attack several months before his death [2]

Robinson died three days later after the attack [3]

His family have been campaigning for information from the IRA and Sinn Fein about the murder [4]

The family also appealed to the IRA to publicise the results of an alleged internal investigation into the attack [5]

Bart Fisher, currently jailed for manslaughter for the murder of James McGinley (11.10.03), is alleged to have been involved in Robinson's murder [6]

  Four individuals were arrested but no charges were made [1]

[1] Lost Lives: Other victims of the IRA, The Guardian, 11 march 2005

[2] Publicise results family tells IRA, Irish News, 26 March 2005

[3] IRA 'must come clean over murder, Irish News, 29 July 2005

[4] Sinn Fein urged to investigate murder, Irish News, 17 August 2005

[5] Brother rejects killer's denial, Irish News, 07 Mardh 2005

 

 

04-May-01

Paul Daly

38

M

C

Civilian

IRA?

Belfast city centre

Co Antrim

Shot while sitting in his car outside a relative’s home in Belfast city centre in broad daylight. Two men escaped form the scene in a waiting Nissan car that was stolen in the Shankill. Mr Daly’s partner and 11-year-old daughter witnessed the murder. Mr Daly was claimed to be a top drug-dealer, and there was speculation of IRA involvement in the murder.[1]

His family strenuously denied that he was a drug-dealer [2]

 

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] Girl ‘traumatised’ by dad’s murder, by Anne Madden, Irish News, 14 May 2001

26-May-01

Stephen Manners

40

M

P

Former UVF

LVF?

Newtownards

Co Down

Former UVF man shot several times in the lavatory of Jimmy Mac’s bar in Newtownards as part of the loyalist feud. Mr Manners had been jailed in connection with the 1992 murder of Ann-Marie Smyth, and had recently appeared in court on drugs-related charges.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Loyalist feud fear as terrorist is shot dead in pub, by David Sharrock, Daily Telegraph, 29 May 2001

11-Jun-01

Michael Magee

34

M

C

Civilian

Unknown

Downpatrick

Co Down

Alleged drug dealer died in bed 3 weeks after a savage paramilitary-style beating by three masked men that had required a number of staples to his head[1].

[1] Widow hits out at drug dealer ‘lie’, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 15 June 2001

23-Jun-01

John McCormick

25

M

C

Civilian

UDA

Coleraine

Co Derry

Shot several times in the head and stomach at his home in Loughanhill Park, Coleraine, in front of his family. McCormick was due to be a witness in a prosecution arising out of the UDA/UVF feud concerning an August 2000 incident in which an 11-year-old girl, Charlene Daly, was shot in the back, allegedly by the UVF. Although Mr McCormick was giving evidence for the Crown’s case, some members of the UDA had accused him of being part of the shooting. Three weeks before the attack, his home was pipe-bombed, and two weeks before that, a man tried to leave a suspicious package in the garden.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

A 37-year-old man who was accused of withholding information about the killing was released on bail on 27 July 2001[2]. A 28-year-old man was charged with the murder in February 2003[3].

     

[1] UDA blamed for murder, by Anne Madden, Irish News, 25 June 2001

[3] Bail set in McCormick case, Irish News, 28 July 2001

[3] Murder accused in court, Irish News, 19 February 2003

Joseph McConnell (37 in 2001), Ian George Hanson (28 in 2003)

04-Jul-01

Ciaran Cummings

19

M

C

Civilian

UVF or RHD

Antrim

Co Antrim

Shot as he waited for a lift at Greystone Roundabout in Antrim by a passenger on a passing motorcycle. The Cummings family has since been subjected to attacks on their home and the monuments erected in Ciaran’s memory.[1] The Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility for the murder, saying it was an attack on the nationalist community in response to a Sinn Féin victory at the polls. The Irish Times said that renegade members of the UVF committed the murder, possibly as a reprisal for the killing of PUP member Denver Smith.[2]

"New evidence probed in Cummings murder"  Police arrested two suspects but, they were released without charge.  A file was sent to the DPP relating to the important new evidence.[4]

As of 16 July 2003, no one had been charged with the murder even though the Police Service allegedly knows the identity of the killer[3].

In 2004 SDLP leader Mark Durkan wrote to Chief Constable Hugh Orde expressing concerns that no-one had been charged over the murder. The PSNI intended to establish a special police team to investigate unresolved paramilitary murders [4], but as of 2006, they were yet to charge anyone [5]

   

[1] Victim’s mum meets top cop, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 25 June 2003

[2] Murder ‘was work of UVF renegades’, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 10 December 2001

[3] Wall of silence shields Gerard’s killers, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 16 July 2003

[4] Sunday Life, 11 April 2004

[5] Unsolved murders team still not set up, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 09/02/2004

[6] ] Daniel’s killers are ‘agents’, Irelandclick, 26/01/2006

 

 

10-Jul-01

Geraldine Ewing

61

F

C

Civilian

Loyalists

Lisburn

Co Antrim

A disabled woman who died of heart attack hours after being ordered to leave her home on the Old Warren estate in Lisburn by a gang of 6 loyalists. The gang had threatened her family that they would be ‘burnt out’ if they did not leave.[1]

[1] Woman dies after gang attack, by Andrea McKernon, Irish News, 11 July 2001

14-Jul-01

Seamus ‘Shavo’ Hogan

47

M

U

Civilian

IRA?

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Drug dealer struck by two shots of at least seven that were fired as he drove into the Transport Club. Mr Hogan was allegedly involved in drugs and the 1986 Beit art collection heist. He gained enemies in the 1980s when it was believed he was feeding information to the gardai.[1] He had allegedly refused to give the IRA a cut of his profits[2], and also had ongoing rows with the INLA, IRA, and criminal elements[3].

 

Drugs-related killing?

[1] IRA ‘may have killed’ Hogan, by Valerie Robinson, Irish News, 17 July 2001

[2] Gardai contact IRA in murder probe, by Cormac O’Keeffe, Irish Examiner, 24 July 2001

[3] Gardai have open mind as to killers of ‘Shavo’ Hogan, by Jim Cusack, Irish Times, 17 July 2001

29-Jul-01

Gavin Brett

18

M

P

Civilian

UDA / RHD

Glengormley

Co Antrim

18-year-old shot in a drive-by killing near the GAA club in Glengormley, where he was celebrating a friend’s birthday in a mixed group of young people. His killers thought he was a Catholic. A Catholic youth, Michael Farrell, was also injured in the shooting. The Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility for the attack, but security assessments linked the shooting with the UDA, which was on ceasefire at the time.[1]

In August 2001, a 36-year-old man was charged with withholding information about the killing on 3 August 2001[2]. Two men were arrested in the murder investigation[3]

As of January 2006, no one had been charged with the murder, despite allegations that the PSNI know the identity of the killer [4]

 

Gerry Adams demanded that Tony Blair face  up to allegations of collusion surrounding the death [5]

     

[1] Loyalist ceasefire still intact, insists UDP, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 8 August 2001

[2] Brett murder case remand, Irish News, 6 August 2001

[3] Two men arrested in Brett murder, by Frank McNamara, Irish News, 4 August 2001

[4] Wall of silence shields Gerard’s killers, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 16 July 2003

[5] Daniel’s killers are ‘agents’, Irelandclick, 26/01/2006

[6] Blair challenged over killings of catholics, U.TV, 30/07/2003

 

Kenneth Samuel Wallace (36 in 2001)

16-Aug-01

David McDowell

34

M

P

Civilian

Republicans?

West Belfast

Co Antrim

34-year-old Protestant beaten to death walking from one property to another while moving house[1].

A number of Catholic men who were shot in republican paramilitary–style attacks shortly after the killing were subsequently questioned by the police. One went into hiding after being released by the police. None were charged because police believed they had destroyed evidence crucial to a possible conviction.[2]

   

[1] Heartfelt grief for murdered brother, by Maeve Connolly, Irish News, 16 August 2002

[2] Suspect in murder case in hiding, UTV News, 15 August 2002

04-Sep-01

Thomas McDonald

16

M

P

Civilian

Civilian

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Teenage loyalist hit by a car while he was throwing objects at cars at a sectarian flashpoint in north Belfast. The killing came during a week of loyalist protests staged in front of a Catholic girls’ primary school (Holy Cross) near a predominantly Protestant area. The driver of the car, Alison McKeown, is a Catholic who allegedly hit Thomas McDonald and knocked him off his bicycle deliberately after he had thrown a brick at her windscreen.[1]

Alison McKeown (33 in 2003) was acquitted of the murder but convicted of manslaughter by reason of provocation and was sentenced to two years in jail and two years of probation. Community members are campaigning for a stiffer sentence through a petition to Westminster, meetings, and rallies.[2]

   

[1] ‘Holy Cross’ death was manslaughter, by Thomas Harding, Belfast Telegraph, 11 January 2003

[2] Petition call over killer’s sentence, by Jonathan McCambridge, Belfast Telegraph, 1 July 2003

28-Sep-01

Martin O’Hagan

51

M

C

Civilian

LVF / RHD

Lurgan

Co Armagh

Sunday World journalist murdered in a drive-by shooting while walking home from pub with his wife in Lurgan. Mr O’Hagan, whose beat was paramilitaries and crime, had coined the name ‘King Rat’ for Billy Wright and was in the process of writing a book about loyalist Robin Jackson.[1] The murder weapon used in the shooting was also used to kill Grahame Marks[2].

On the night of the murder, O’Hagan had been threatened by loyalists on his way home from a pub in Lurgan with his wife. During the fatal drive by shooting, O’Hagan had pushed his wife to safety into a hedge. (6)

At the time of the murder the Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility for the killing, but media sources believed that the men responsible had links with the mid-Ulster Loyalist Volunteer Force. (6)

 

No one had been charged in the murder as of June 2003, though the identities of the killers are supposedly known in the area and in media circles. The lead suspect is believed to be on the run, perhaps in hiding in England or Spain.[3]

The National Union of Jurists asked that the investigation be handed over to an independent force as there are allegations that the police know who was responsible but are protecting them. As of 2005, there was still no conviction [4]

Following enquiries by the Retrospective Murder Review Team (set up to re-investigate murders committed between June 1998 and June 2004) five men were arrested in connection with the murder in the Lurgan and Banbridge areas on 10/9/08. (5) Three of the individuals were charged with murder (Drew King, 40, Nigel Leckey, 43, and Neil Hyde, 28), one with attempting to pervert the course of justice (Robin King, 42, by disposing of the Subaru getaway car) and one with assisting the offenders (Mark Kennedy, 28). (7) The arrests had come after a police statement from Witness A. (9)

One of the men charged with murder, Drew King, threatens a legal challenge against the prison service after being held in a punishment cell in Maghaberry prison since his arrest. Police staff had argued that the measure was necessary after it emerged that King had an ongoing friendship with a former female prison officer (9)

 

   

[1] Faith, Hate, and Murder, by Susan McKay, Guardian, 17 November 2001

[2] How the UDA kept its peace, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 13 October 2001

[3] ‘Guidance’ needed on unsolved murders, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 24 June 2003

[4] Police asked to hand over O’Hagan probe, by Jon Slattery, Press Gazette, 29/09/2005

(5) Police granted more time to quiz suspects in O’Hagan murder case, staff reporter, Irish News, 12/9/08

(6) Five held over journalist Martin O’Hagan murder, Belfast Telegraph, 11/9/08

(7) Four charged over reporter murder, BBC News, 16/9/08

(8) Suspect to challenge conditions, Allison Morris, Irish News, 3/10/08

(9) ‘Witness A’ had left the area, Lurgan Mail, 20/11/08

 

20? Oct 01

Hugh Cameron

36

M

U

Civilian

UDA / RHD?

Glenarm

Co Antrim

Welder from Carrickfergus who disappeared after a night drinking at a bar in east Antrim town on October 20. His mutilated body, with multiple stab wounds to the head and body, was discovered in the River Skeagh four weeks later. As of April 2002, the police said that they had been unable to develop a motive or charge anyone with the murder.[1] The Irish News reported that the police were linking loyalists with the murder[2].

Four men were arrested in December 2001, but were released without charge[3].

The murder was re-enacted for the BBC’s Crimewatch UK programme. [4]

   

[1] BBC to help in murder inquiry, by Patricia O’Hara, Irish News, 15 April 2002

[2] Loyalists linked to Cameron murder, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 6 December 2001

[3] Loyalists linked to Cameron murder, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 6 December 2001

[4] BBC to help in murder inquiry, by Patricia O’Hara, Irish News, 15/04/2002

29-Oct-01

Charles Folliard

30

M

P

Former UDA

Republicans

Strabane

Co Tyrone

Shot by two men while seated in his car outside his girlfriend’s home. The gunmen pushed his 16-year-old girlfriend aside and shot him six times. The gun used was a police-issue Heckler & Koch MP5, which had been missing for a year. Two police officers have since been disciplined over the disappearance of the gun. The victim had been freed three years before after spending seven years in jail over a plot to murder a Catholic workmate, and had severed his loyalist ties.[1] Police named the INLA as main suspects in the killing, even though the Continuity IRA claimed responsibility[2].

[1] Police point finger at INLA after killing of Protestant man, by Rosie Cowan, Guardian, 9 November 2001

[2] Shooting triggers INLA threat to kill top loyalists, by Liam Clarke, Sunday Times, 13 January 2002

29-Oct-01

Peter McNally

19

M

U

Civilian

Unknown

Craigavon

Co Armagh

19-year-old shot twice in the head by 2 men while sleeping in a house on the Westacres estate in Drumgor. It was believed that he was on the run from a Youth Offenders Centre and that he was the victim of a paramilitary-style attack a few months before the killing.[1] Police originally linked the killing to criminal activities rather than sectarianism[2].

Two men, ages 47 and 28, were charged with the murder in 2001. Two others who had been arrested were released without charge.[3]

Hugh McGeough (49) and Raymond Hearney (30) both pleaded guilty to unlawfully and maliciously wounding the victim, and were acquitted of murder. They were sentenced to 9 and 10 years respectively. [4]

 

     

[1] Two held in connection with murder, by Bimpe Fatogun, Irish News, 30 October 2001

[2] Soldier faces murder charge, BBC News, 30 October 2001

[3] Murder charge: two in custody, by Anne Madden, Irish News, 2 November 2001

[4] Second gunman acquitted in McNally murder case, Irish News, 21/01/2004

Hugh Francis McGeogh and Raymond Heaney (47 and 28 in 2001)

11-Nov-01

Glen Branagh

16

M

P

UDA

Self inflicted

North Belfast

Co Antrim

16-year-old member of UDA youth wing killed when a pipe bomb he was preparing to throw exploded prematurely during rioting in north Belfast. Evidence at the inquest showed the pipe bomb originated on the loyalist side of the lines, despite loyalist claims to the contrary.[1]

[1] Inquest says teenager died by own pipe bomb, by Barry McCaffrey and Kieran McDaid, Irish News, 29 April 2003

03-Dec-01

Francis (Frankie) ‘Boogaloo’ Mulholland

34

M

C

Former INLA

LVF / RHD

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Former INLA man and drugs dealer shot while sitting in stationary car opposite a petrol station on Upper Crumlin Road. Mr Mulholland was thought to have been murdered by loyalists who alleged that he had double-crossed them over a drugs deal. Cocaine was found in his vehicle. The Irish News reported that members of the UFF’s 2nd Battlion ‘C’ company were the chief suspects in the killing, though the Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility. Mr Mulholland was on both a loyalist and a republican hit list.[1] One of the guns used to kill Mr Mulholland was also used in the murder of Billy Stobie and was linked to recent UDA/UFF violence in north Belfast[2].

[1] UFF unit ‘suspects in killing’, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 8 December 2001

[2] Stobie weapon link, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 21 December 2001

12-Dec-01

William (Billy) Stobie

51

M

P

Former UDA

UDA / RHD

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Former SB informer shot dead outside his home on Forthriver Road. His trial for aiding and abetting murder of Pat Finucane collapsed two weeks before he was killed when the prosecution’s chief witness declined to testify on grounds of ill health. Mr Stobie had appeared on UTV documentary admitting to being a Special Branch informer. The killing was claimed by the Red Hand Defenders, but a senior loyalist said shortly after the death that the UFF committed the murder because Stobie had ‘stuck two fingers up’ to the organisation.[1]

The weapon used was the same as one of the weapons used to kill Francis Mulholland and was linked to recent UDA/UFF violence in north Belfast[2].

Former UDA leader Johnny Adair was heavily investigated following the murder, although not as a suspect for he was in jail at the time. [3]

Ten days before he was killed, Stobie was warned by the PSNI that his life was at risk. Lawyers acting on his behalf requested that he be allowed to join the Key Person’s protection scheme after the case against him collapsed. [4]

The Police Ombudsman ruled that the police had done all they could to reasonably protect him. [5]

The UN Special Rapporteur on the Independence of Judges and Lawyers (Dato Cumaraswamy) claimed that Stobie may have been killed by the same people who killed Patrick Finucane, as Stobie supported an independent inquiry into Finucane’s murder. [4]

{See: http://www.birw.org/patrick%20finucane%20case.html}

 

[1] Taking his secrets to the grave, by Brian McCaffrey, Irish News, 13 December 2001

[2] Stobie weapon link, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 21 December 2001

[3] Adair investigated over Stobie murder, Irish News, 20/10/2005

[4] Stobie was ‘silenced’ claim, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 18/12/2001

[5] Police backed over killing, BBC News, 04/07/2004

 

12-Dec-01

Derek Lenehan

27

M

C

INLA

INLA

Forkhill

Co Armagh

Died several hours after being taken from a pub at 9:00pm on 11 December 2001, bound, shot in the thighs, and abandoned along a roadside in the Forkhill area, South Armagh. This was thought to be a punishment beating that had gone wrong.[1] A 35-year-old was also shot in the left leg but survived[2]. The murder was believed to have been linked to an internal INLA feud over the proceeds of robberies that the INLA had not yet received[3].

[1] Murder ‘was punishment attack that went wrong’, by Simon Doyle, Irish News, 13 December 2001

[2] INLA ‘may have killed Dublin man’, by Simon Doyle, Irish News¸ 13 December 2001

[3] INLA man’s killing may be linked to feud, Irish Independent, 13 December 2001

03-Jan-02

William Campbell

19

M

P

UDA

Self inflicted

Coleraine

Co Derry

Teenager died in an alley behind his home when a pipe bomb he was handling exploded. An electronic timer was used in the pipe bomb, which indicated that such bombs might be used in the future as booby trap devices.[1] His death was at the height of a UDA campaign of pipe bomb attacks on Catholics in the area. In August 2002 the UDA erected a memorial in his memory.[2]

[1] Teenager ‘was member of UDA’, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 5 January 2002

[2] UDA tribute to teen ‘own-goal’ bomber, by Ciaran McGuigan, Belfast Telegraph, 25 August 2002

12-Jan-02

Daniel McColgan

20

M

C

Civilian

UDA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

20-year-old Catholic postman shot by two gunmen as he reported for work in the loyalist Rathcoole estate. In February 2002, the police took the unusual step of offering a £20,000 reward, which was provided by a number of groups, in an attempt to catch the loyalist killers.[1] A UDA member who became the new leader of the South East Antrim Brigade of the UDA in February 2000 was reportedly involved with the shooting[2].

As of July 2003, no one had been charged with the murder[3].

Four years after the killing, a spokesperson for the PSNI said that detectives remained determined to bring the killers to justice. However a local priest claimed the police are protecting the suspects as they are informers. [4]

   

[1] £20,000 for information on killers, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 26 February 2002

[2] New UDA brigadier link to McColgan and Quail murders, by Stephen McGoldrick, Irelandclick.com, 28 February 2003

[3] Grief and friendship unite families of murder victims, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 16 July 2003

[4] Man’s killers are agents,  by Ciaran Barnes, Daily Ireland, 31/01/2006

16-Jan-02

Stephen McCullough

39

M

P

UDA

UDA?

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Mr McCullough’s body was found at the bottom of Cavehill a few days after Daniel McColgan’s murder. He had reportedly told the police he had some information about Mr McColgan’s death, but he died before he could be interviewed. Shortly before his death, the PSNI arrested him for suspected drunk driving and, upon his release, offered him a lift home, which he refused.[1] His case is being investigated by Police Ombudsman Nuala O’Loan[2].

[1] £20,000 for information on killers, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 26 February 2002

[2] Loyalist’s death to be probed by O’Loan, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 21 January 2002

21-Feb-02

Matthew Burns

26

M

C

Civilian

IRA?

Castlewellan

Co Down

Died in his car just after 7:00 pm on the Burren Bridge Road near Castlewellan when gunmen opened fire on the car. His brother Patrick was also shot in the chest and arm but managed to crawl to a pub for help. The victim was said to have links to drugs. He had been severely beaten in the past and was also the victim of a pipe bomb attack in Newcastle in 2001.[1] The IRA was blamed, but Sinn Féin denied any mainstream republican involvement in the killing.[2]

Three people who were arrested in connection with the killing were released without charge[3].

At the inquest, the PSNI said that he was shot dead as part of a personal vendetta, after an incident with a group of republicans, and that all drug-related allegations were a ‘smokescreen’’ [4]

   

[1] Man was murdered in revenge allegation, by Liz Trainor, Irish News, 23 February 2002

[2] Republicans deny IRA involved, by Kieran McDaid and PA News, Irish News, 23 February 2002

[3] No charges brought in Burns case, Irish News, 27 June 2002

[4] Appeal after murdered son smeared as ‘dealer’, by Philip Bradfield, Newsletter, 13/04/2005

17-Apr-02

Brian (Barney) McDonald

51

M

C

Civilian

Unknown

near Dungannon

Co Tyrone

Catholic taxi driver shot four times by two gunmen shortly before 11pm after being called to pick up a fare at a snooker club in Donaghmore, near Dungannon. Though the Red Hand Defenders claimed responsibility, Mr McDonald’s family has said they think republicans are behind the killing because of the family’s history of feuding with the IRA. Six weeks earlier Mr McDonald had been in a fight with an IRA man, and his life had been threatened by the IRA. One son was injured in an IRA punishment beating two years earlier.[1] On the day of the killing one of his sons allegedly threatened someone’s life and another son attempted to dispose of the mobile telephone used. They were charged for these actions, but were released on bail to attend their father’s funeral.[2]

Following mixed police reports and missing files, his family believe the police are protecting an informer [3]

The Police Ombudsman carried out an investigation into the family’s allegations, and concluded that the police had conducted a proper and thorough investigation. The case is currently being investigated by the Serious Crime Review Team. [5]

A well-known Dungannon republican who had been jailed in the 1980s for arms and explosives offences was arrested and questioned about the murder, but was released without charge[3].

   

[1] Family of Co Tyrone taxi-driver blame IRA for his killing, by Suzanne Breen, Irish Times, 19 April 2002

[2] Murdered man’s sons are bailed, BBC News, 18 April 2002

[3] Man held over taxi killing is released, by Roddy McGregor, Irish News, 22 April 2002

4] 'PSNI accused of cover-up in a taxi-driver murder case' by Bimpe Fatogun, Irish News, 15 November 2005

[5] Slain cabbie’s family make cover-up claims, by Ciaran McGuigan, Belfast Telegraph, 02/04/2006

10-Jun-02

Mark ‘Swinger’ Fulton

42

M

P

LVF

Self inflicted

Mughaberry prison, near Lisburn

Co Antrim

Found dead in his cell in Mughaberry prison, lying on his bed with a leather belt around his neck, without a note. Two post-mortem examinations ruled that it was suicide.[1] The Irish News alleged that Mr Fulton had links to twelve sectarian killings, including the murder of solicitor Rosemary Nelson. The year before his death he had denied that he was involved in killing journalist Martin O’Hagan.[2]

[1] Loyalist leaders unite for LVF funeral, by Simon Doyle, Irish News, 15 June 2002

[2] Fulton linked to 12 sectarian killings, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 11 June 2002

22-Jul-02

Gerard Lawlor

19

M

C

Civilian

UFF / UDA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Catholic shot at least five times near his Whitewell Road home just after midnight following a day and night of rioting in north Belfast. The death presumably came in retaliation for the injuring of a 19-year-old Protestant man and after another Catholic was wounded by a gunshot. Mr Lawlor was targeted because he was wearing a Glasgow Celtic jersey.[1] The UFF claimed responsibility for the murder[2]. In August 2002 it was speculated that he was killed by the same weapon used to murder Sam Rockett in the loyalist feud in August 2000[3]. In July 2003, police said they knew who killed him, but there was no prospect of charges because they did not have enough evidence to convict. The Detective Superintendent said that the LVF, acting on the orders of the UFF Shankill ‘C company,’ is suspected of being behind the murder.[4]

No arrests had been made and no houses searched as of July 2003, because, according to police, the silence in the loyalist community has prevented them from gathering enough evidence to charge anyone[5].

The PSNI publicly admitted they knew the identity of the killers but did not have sufficient evidence to convict them. [6]

   

[1] No rest for the guns, by Henry McDonald, Sunday Observer, 28 July 2002

[2] A catalogue of murder, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 23 July 2002

[3] Hutchinson confirms murder weapon claims, by Allison Morris, Irelandclick.com, 9 August 2002

[4] We know who killed Gerard say police, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 16 July 2003

[5] Wall of silence shields Gerard’s killers, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 16 July 2003

[6] Murder probe ‘still active’ two years on, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 15/07/2004

01-Aug-02

David Caldwell

51

M

P

Former UDR

RIRA

Derry

Co Derry

51-year-old construction worker and former UDR soldier killed when he picked up an explosives-laden lunch box at the Territorial Army base in Derry. The Real IRA claimed responsibility for the murder three weeks later.[1]

Five people who were immediately arrested and questioned over the murder were released without charge[2].

Another man was arrested and questioned the following week[3],

And two more were arrested a week later following ten house searches in Derry. All three were released without charge.[4]

The PSNI admitted they knew the identity of the killers but did not have sufficient evidence to convict them. [5]

   

[1] Real IRA carried out murder, by Roddy McGregor, Irish News, 22 August 2002

[2] Murder hunt: five freed, Belfast Telegraph, 4 August 2002

[3] Man arrested over booby-trap murder, Irish Times, 8 August 2002

[4] Two released – no charges, Irish News, 16 August 2002

[5] Call to seize Real IRA unit, by Ciaran O’Neill, Belfast Telegraph, 05/02/2004

12-Aug-02

Christopher Whitson

20

M

C

Civilian

Loyalists

Portrush

Co Antrim

Died in hospital following a sectarian attack on 4 August 2002 outside Kelly’s nightclub in Portrush, where he had been celebrating his brother’s birthday[1]. The attack allegedly began when Mr Whitson was identified as a Catholic[2].

In 2002, three men, ages 23, 20, and 28, were charged with murder in connection with the attack. All three were released on bail in September 2002.[3]

Gary Davison (31) and Gillian rose Agnew (24) were found guilty of manslaughter. Davison was sentenced to 3 years and Agnew for 18 months, plus one year probation for both [4]

     

[1] Sectarian assault victim ‘had bright future ahead’, by Tony Bailie, Irish News, 14 August 2002

[2] Arrests over student attack, by William Scholes, Irish News, 10 August 2002

[3] Murder accused given bail, Irish News, 7 September 2002

[4] Two jailed for manslaughter of student in club car park, Irish News Online, 29/06/2005

 

Robin Neeson, David Gaston, and Gary Davidson (23, 20, and 28 in 2002), all from Broughshane

13-Sep-02

Stephen Warnock

35

M

P

LVF

UDA

Newtownards

Co Down

Leading LVF member shot by two people on a motorcycle as he sat in his car with his 3-year-old daughter and another man outside of a school. The killing was the beginning of another upsurge in the loyalist feud. Following Mr Warnock’s death, UDA leader Jim Gray was shot and wounded by an LVF gunman in retaliation.[1] Jim Johnston, who was killed in May 2003, was suspected of driving the motorcycle used in Mr Warnock’s murder[2]. In May 2003, police released CD-fit images of three men linked to the murder[3]. One LVF figure said at the time that he thought the killing was linked to the murder of Terry Enright in 1998[4].

At the inquiry, the victim’s brother named the former drugs baron Jon Johnston, (who was later killed), as the driver of the motorbike. [5]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Loyalist on witness protection programme, UTV, 21 September 2002

[2] Murder tarnishes image of Ulster's smart Gold Coast, by David Lister, The Times, 10 May 2003

[3] Police hunt trio over killing of LVF drug baron, by Ashleigh Wallace, Belfast Telegraph, 12 May 2003

[4] Drug feud motive suspected in shooting of loyalist paramilitary, by Rosie Cowan, Guardian, 14 September 2002

[5] Drug boss ‘helped murder LVF man’, Belfast Telegraph, 18/08/2005

04-Oct-02

Geoffrey ‘Greyhound’ Gray

41

M

P

LVF

UDA

East Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot once by a lone gunman on Ravenhill Avenue shortly before midnight. A friend of his survived an assassination attempt the following day.[1] Mr Gray was a close associate of Billy Wright who joined the LVF at its formation in 1996[2]. He was also allegedly a drug dealer and an ally of Johnny Adair[3]. Mr Gray had allegedly begun to give information to journalist Martin O’Hagan after the death of Adrian Lampf[4].

The coroner at the inquest described Gray as being on the fringes of both the LVF in Portadown, and the UDA in east Belfast [6]

 

 

 

Loyalist feud

The UDA Brigadier for East Belfast (no relation), was arrested and questioned in relation to the murder. This man had been shot in the face by the LVF in September 2002 in retaliation for the murder of Stephen Warnock.[5]

     

[1] Murder bid bike is focus of appeal, by Aisling McCrea, Irish News, 7 December 2002

[2] Loyalists kill top LVF man, The People, 7 October 2002

[3] Where next?, by Liam Clarke and Lucy Adams, Sunday Times, 9 February 2003

[4] Greyhound Gray turned informer after killing, by Mike Browne, The People, 18 October 2002

[5] Where next?, by Liam Clarke and Lucy Adams, Sunday Times, 9 February 2003

[6] Loyalist’s murder a mystery says coroner, Irish News, 06/09/2005

Jim Gray

13-Oct-02

Alexander McKinley

22

M

P

Loyalist?

LVF

East Belfast

Co Antrim

Shot in the head by an LVF gunman on Euston Street in the Woodstock Road area of Belfast on 7 October 2002 and died in hospital six days later. Before Mr McKinley was shot, the gunman fired at a man in his 30s who escaped unharmed. Both shootings were linked to the recent loyalist feud[1], although the PSNI later suggested that these may have been some other motive for the murder of Mr. McKinley[2].

"Murder not part of a feud"  Two men aged 23 and 27 were remanded in custody until 31/03/04.  Both men had denied murder[3]

Two men were arrested and charged with murder. They were released on bail in 2004. [2]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Loyalist feud victim dies, BBC News, 13 October 2002 [2] Police rethink murder motive, Irish News, 4 October 2003

[2] BBc news, 03 March 2004

[3] Murder accused freed on bail, Irish News, 22/04/2004

11-Nov-02

Thomas Johnston

24

M

P

Civilian

UDA?

West Belfast

Co Antrim

A BMW pulled up beside Mr Johnston and his female friend on 10 November 2002 as they walked home in the early hours in Boundary way on the lower Shankill estate. A man got out of the car and began to assault Mr Johnston with a heavy object, then kicked him as his body lay on the ground. His friend was also hit across the face in the attack.[1] Mr Johnston’s body was exhumed for further examination in February 2003[2].

In February 2003, a 34-year-old man was being held for questioning about the murder[3].

   

[1] Police revisit murder scene, by Patricia O’Hara, Irish News, 18 November 2002

[2] Victim’s body is exhumed, Irish News, 17 February 2003

[3] Man is held over murder, Irish News, 13 February 2003

25-Nov-02

Stephen Byrne

39

M

C

Dissident republican?

RIRA?

Dublin

Republic of Ireland

Mr Byrne was killed by single shot to the back of the head and his body was found lying face down in woods outside Tallaght, Dublin. Gardai suspect that he was a contract killer. He was due to be sentenced for firearms offences. He was also reportedly targeted a month before his murder, when a gunman entered a pub where Mr Byrne was drinking and fired a single shot. Detectives in the case believe Mr Byrne may have been killed in retaliation for a previous attack, possibly a July attack on a house in Inchicore for which Mr Byrne was to be sentenced shortly.[1]

[1] Murder ‘may have been retaliation’, by Valerie Robinson, Irish News, 28 November 2002

30-Nov-02

Mark Apsley

38

M

P

Civilian

UDA

Ballygowan

Co Down

Shot early Saturday evening at his home in Ballygowan, Co Down. As Mr Apsley came to the door, the gunman opened fire through the glass panel and shot him up to six times. Mr Apsley was rumoured to have had a personal dispute with an east Belfast UDA leader. The UDA was the main suspect in the investigation, based on information about the personal dispute.[1]

[1] UDA ‘main suspects’ for murder of father, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 2 December 2002

25-Dec-02

David Cupples

25

M

P

Civilian

UDA?

North Belfast

Co Antrim

25-year-old civilian kitchen porter at Girdwood army base died three days after he was found lying in the street with serious head injuries on 22 December 2002. The injuries were sustained while Mr Cupples was on walking to work through a predominantly loyalist area. Mr Cupples may have been mistaken for a Catholic, as the man accused of murder reportedly told friends that he had ‘got a Taig’[1] and Mr Cupples was killed while walking in the direction of nationalist Cliftonville Road. PSNI said there were similarities with the attack on Thomas Johnston.[2]

William Alan Hill was charged with the murder in January 2003 and refused bail in March 2003[3].

His brother was charged with attempting to dispose of clothing with intent to impede an investigation[4].

Two 20-year-olds were charged with assisting offenders in the murder[5].

 

One of them was also charged with trying to dispose of video evidence[6].

 

In January 2005, Hill admitted to the murder and was sentenced to life imprisonment.  He was subsequently ordered to serve a minimum of thirteen years.[7] 

His brother, Edward David Hill, admitted assisting an offender, and Brian Andrew Dickson and Darren Paul pled guilty to charges of withholding information. [8]

 

William Hill was later sentenced to 11 years for his part in a pipe-bomb attack on an SDLP constituency office [9]

 

     

[1] ‘Taig’ victim a Protestant, Irish News, 7 March 2003

[2] Killers thought victim was Catholic: police, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 27 December 2002

[3] ‘Taig’ victim a Protestant, Irish News, 7 March 2003

[4] Brothers face charges over Christmas killing, Irish News, 7 January 2003

[5] Third arrest in murder probe, by Brian Campbell, Irish News, 2 January 2003

[6] Postal worker held in murder hearing, Irish News, 4 January 2003

[7] Loyalist thug who murdered young chef jailed for 13 years, Irish News, 27 April 2005

[8] Man jailed for life for porter murder, UTV News, 31 January 2005

[9] Murderer jailed for pipe bombing SDLP office, Irish News, 18/05/2005

William Hill (20 in 2003), his brother is Edward David Hill. Darren Paul and Brian Dickson (both 20 in 2003). Dickson was also charged with trying to dispose of video evidence.

27-Dec-02

Jonathan Stewart

22

M

P

Civilian

UDA Adair faction

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Singled out in the kitchen of a house in north Belfast after a party and shot twice in head by a hooded gunman[1]. Mr Stewart had no paramilitary ties personally, but his uncle, a former close associate of Johnny Adair, had recently been in a dispute with Adair’s UDA ‘C company’ faction after being accused of siphoning UDA funds. The family, including Mr Stewart’s girlfriend, had been targeted in recent months with arson attacks, automatic fire at homes, etc.[2]

 

Loyalist feud

A 23-year-old man who was held for questioning shortly after the murder was released without charge. A 64-year-old man had also been arrested and released without charge. Twelve houses had been searched in the investigation.[3] On 15 January 2003, a 17-year-old was charged with possessing a firearm in suspicious circumstances and having a blank firearm and balaclava for terrorist purposes. He was remanded into custody.[4] On 25 July 2003, a 23-year-old, Wayne Stephen Dowie, was charged with Mr Stewart’s murder and remanded into custody[5].  In March 2005, the case against Dowie collapsed. [6]

     

[1] 22-year-old ‘killed for his family ties’, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 28 December 2002

[2] No mediation in sight as UDA bloodletting continues, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 28 December 2002

[3] Murder suspect leaves custody, by Brian Campbell, Irish News, 4 January 2003

[4] Teen held in custody, Irish News, 16 January 2003

[5] Man charged with murder, BBC News, 26 July 2003

[6] Dowie murder trial aborted, UTV News, 7 March 2005

Daniel Anderson (17 in 2003), Wayne Stephen Dowie (23 in 2003)

02-Jan-03

Roy Green

32

M

P

UDA Adair faction

UDA

South Belfast

Co Antrim

Ally of Johnny Adair, shot as he left the Kimberley bar at around 7.00pm as part of the loyalist feud begun in September. Another man escaped unhurt.[1] The UDA claimed responsibility, accusing the victim in a statement of committing ‘treason’ by secretly scheming against the UDA with Adair[2].

Iain Rea (35) has been charged with the murder, and the possession of four guns, plastic explosives and a detonator, and possession of imitation firearms with intent to cause fear. The gun used to kill Green was found, and Rea’s fingerprints were on documents and a bin liner in the same location. He is currently released on bail. [3]

 

Loyalist feud

[1] Loyalist war fears after new murder, by Jamie Wilson, Guardian, 4 January 2003

[2] Loyalists killed own member for ‘treason’, Irish Independent, 4 January 2003

[3]Man in court over murder , Irish News Online, 27/01/2006

01-Feb-03

John ‘Grugg’ Gregg

45

M

P

UDA

UDA Adair faction / RHD

Belfast

Co Antrim

UFF South East Antrim hardline leader shot in a taxi leaving the Belfast docks after he returned from a Rangers/Celtic match in Glasgow. The shooting was part of the UDA/Adair faction loyalist feud. Gregg, who was linked to a number of recent sectarian killings, gave a newspaper interview hours before his death in which he warned members of Adair’s faction to settle the dispute or risk a “move against them.”[1] His shooting was followed by a large exodus of people related to the Adair faction and several revenge attacks, including mass vandalism of Adair’s offices, homes, posters, and murals.[2] He was the highest-ranking UDA member to be assassinated since 1994[3].

 

Loyalist feud

Two men were questioned immediately after the murders[4].

In April 2003, the police arrested four people as they returned to Belfast on a ferry from Scotland[5].

 Six associates of Adair were arrested on 8 July 2003, three from Bolton, Greater Manchester, and three from the Shankill area, but all were released without charge[6].

As of 2006, no-one had been charged [7]

   

[1] Gregg may have used trips to Scotland as murder alibi, Irish News, 3 February 2003

[2] Funeral shots send loyalist renegades into exile, by David Lister, Times, 7 February 2003

[3] Gregg murder said to be a hired hit, by Jack Holland, Irish Echo, 12-18 February 2003

[4] Gregg murder: two quizzed, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 3 February 2003

[5] In brief: four held for UDA murder, Guardian, 10 April 2003

[6] Six freed in loyalist murder probe, Irish News, 9 July 2003

[7] Loyalist car bomb accused acquitted, Irish News, 22/02/2006

02-Feb-03

Robert ‘Rab’ Carson

33

M

P

UDA

UDA Adair faction / RHD

Belfast

Co Antrim

UDA member who was shot in the taxi with John Gregg and died early Sunday morning in the hospital[1]. (see above)

 

Loyalist feud

(see above)

   

[1] Gregg murder: two quizzed, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 3 February 2003

12-Mar-03

Keith Rogers

24

M

C

IRA

Former IRA

Cullaville

Republic of Ireland

Reportedlly shot while he and seven others were in the process of administering on attempted punishment beating. A man in a car fired on the attackers, killing Keith Rogers and wounding two other men. Both the victim of the beating and the gunman were said to have refused to pay money extorted by the IRA from the proceeds of diesel and cigarette smuggling.[1]

[1] Extortion racket led to IRA killings, by Jim Cusack, Sunday Independent, 7 September 2003.

08-May-03

Jim ‘Jonty’ Johnston

45

M

P

RHC

LVF?

Crawfordsburn

Co Down

Senior figure in the Red Hand Commando shot by two gunmen as part of a loyalist feud in the drive of his home on the Ballyrobert Road near Crawfordsburn[1]. The gun had been used in two prior killings[2]. The Crown lawyer arguing the case alleged that it was committed in revenge for the killing of Stephen Warnock, the brother-in-law of the accused’s sister[3]. Mr Johnston was suspected of driving the motorcycle used in Mr Warnock’s murder. Mr Johnston had also allegedly been a suspect in the murders of Adrian Porter and William Paul.[4] A month and a half after the murder, a bomb and bullets were discovered on Mr Johnston’s property[5].

 

Loyalist feud?

One man was arrested soon after the shooting but released without charge. Another man from Mid-Ulster was arrested on 23 May 2003.[6] On 26 May 2003, a 39-year-old [Robert Young]  man was charged with murder and his 37-year-old sister [Lorraine Young] was charged with providing him with a false alibi[7].  In September 2003 a 17 year-old youth appeared in court charged with being in possession of two balaclavas in connection with the murder. [8]   In June 2005, Robert Young was convicted of the murder and sentenced to life imprisonment.  His sister was also convicted of providing false alibi and another woman, Susan Ferguson, was convicted for possession of a pistol magazine. [9]

 

     

[1] Hunt for killers continues as politicians urge calm, by Sharon O’Neill, Irish News, 10 May 2003

[2] Johnston killing – man held by police, by William Scholes, Irish News, 13 May 2003

[3] Red Hand killing was ‘revenge’, Irish News, 29 May 2003

[4] Murder tarnishes image of Ulster's smart Gold Coast, by David Lister, The Times, 10 May 2003

[5] Three held over bomb find, BBC News, 25 June 2003

[6] Man held over loyalist killing, in News Briefs, Irish News, 24 May 2003

[7] Red Hand killing was ‘revenge’, Irish News, 29 May 2003

[8]  Man in court over murder, Irish News, 29 September 2003

[9]  Johnson's killer already planning murder appeal, Irish News, 10 June 2005

Robert John Young (39 in 2003), Lorraine Young (37 in 2003)

11? May 03

Gareth O’Connor – disappeared, presumed dead

24

M

C

RIRA

IRA?

Armagh

Co Armagh

Dissident republican who went missing from his home in Armagh on 11 May 2003 after setting out to report to Dundalk Garda Síochána as part of bail conditions imposed for charges of membership of an illegal organisation. Several months later, he had not been seen or heard from, his car has not been spotted, and he was presumed dead. His family blame the Provisional IRA, who had a dispute with O’Connor about a collapsed pyramid investment scheme.[1]

 

IRA on dissidents?

Three people have been questioned with regard to the disappearance, but no one has been charged[2].

   

[1] Family of missing man ‘feeling pretty helpless’, by William Scholes, Irish News, 12 July 2003

[2] Family of missing man ‘feeling pretty helpless’, by William Scholes, Irish News, 12 July 2003

28? May 03

Alan McCullough

21

M

P

UDA Adair faction

UDA

North Belfast

Co Antrim

Member of the Adair faction who returned to Northern Ireland from England, apparently after receiving assurances that he would not be attacked. He was last seen getting into a blue car outside his Shankhill home in the company of 2 senior UDA men, Ihab Skoukri and Mo Courtney, on 28 May 2003. He is said to have been involved with the murders of Jonathan Stewart and John Gregg. His body was found in a shallow grave on the outskirts of north Belfast on 5 June 2003.[1]

 

Loyalist feud

Two senior loyalists, ages 29 and 39, were charged with his murder in June 2003[2].

William ‘Mo’ Courtney was released on bail,  but was returned to Maghaberry prison in March 2006 after he broke his curfew conditions. [3]

Willliam ‘Mo’ Courtney was acquitted of the murder of Alan McCullough and membership to the UDA and UFF, on 28 November 2006. Courtney was tried in the Diplock Court. Justice McLaughlin said there was ‘inherent weakness’ in the evidence given by the McCullough and witness A. The prosecution have the right to appeal the decision. [4]

     

[1] Grim last supper for suspected UDA victim, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 6 June 2003

[2] Accused denied bail in feud case, Irish News, 21 June 2003

[3] Courtney in prison after breaking nail curfew, by Barry McCaffrey¸ Irish News, 30/03/2006

[4] Loyalist cleared on murder charge, BBC News, 28 November 2006

Ihab Skoukri and William ‘Mo’ Courtney (29 and 39 in 2003)

17-Aug-03

Danny McGurk

35

M

C

Civilian

RIRA

West Belfast

Co Antrim

Father of six gunned down at his home off the Lower Falls, the day after he had allegedly gone out armed with a knife looking for dissident republicans said to have beaten him up for urinating against a house. The two gunmen shot him in the chest, thigh and ankle. He died later in hospital.[1]

"Real IRA denial can't be trusted"  Detectives have made several arrests and charges have been brought but, no-one has faced a charge of murder.[2]

[1]  RIRA gunmen kill Belfast man at his home, UTV News, 18 August 2003

[2]  Irish News, 10 January 2004

08-Nov-03

John Allen

31

M

P

UVF?

UVF

Ballyclare

Co Antrim

Two masked men  fired at him at his home, wounding him in the legs and head.  He later died in hospital.  He was reported as being a former UVF member.[1] Later his father said that he sustained two bullet wounds to the head and no other wounds.  He also said that he was killed because he had stood up to the UVF.[2]

[1] Murder victim linked to loyalists, BBC TV News, 9 November 2003 [2]UVF 'sanctioned murder', Belfast Telegraph, 10 November 2003

 

11-Oct-03 James McGinley 23 M    

Alleged IRA member

Dery

 

 

McGinley was stabbed through the heart, following a confrontation with a group of men at around 3am.  The incident was caught on CCTV.  A  policewoman attending the murder scene was injured by a crowd as she gave first aid. [1] 

The McGinley family later alleged that they had been intimidated by the IRA, who were protecting the killer. [2]

 Bart Fisher was arrested and charged with the murder on 13 October 2003. [3] 

Witnesses were allegedly prevented from coming forward by the IRA and Fisher was convicted on a lesser charge of manslaughter, and sentenced to three years imprisonment.[4]

 

1] Officer hurt at murder scene, BBC News, 11 Oct 2005

[2] Sinn Fein shields another knife killer, The Times Online, 6 March 2005

[3] Clashes as murder accused faces court, Irish News, 14 Oct 2003

[4] Adams to meet McGinley family, UTV News, 3 April 2005

 

21-Nov-03 James McMahon 21 M C

Civilian

? Lisburn

Co Antrim

Three masked men  beat him with baseball bat suffering serious head injuries.  He died in hospital the next day.[1]

[1] Three arrested in murder inquiry, BBC News, 4 December 2003

  Kieran Keane 36 M       Drombana Limerick Men jailed for life after being convicted of the murder of Kieran Keane and the attempted murder of his nephew and two counts of false imprisonment.[1] [1] Limerick crime boss murderers jailed for life, Irish News, 22 December 2003
24 -Mar -04 Andrew Cully 47 M       Greyabbey   Man aged 47 was shot dead in an alleyway at a loyalist housing estate in Co Down.  One man was arrested.  Another man was released without charge after being questioned.[1] [2] Man quizzed over NI murder, UTV, 02 April 2004
18-May-04 Brian Stewart 34 M P LVF UVF East Belfast Co Antrim

Mr Stewart was shot dead in a gun attack as he arrived at work.  Sources believe loyalist paramilitaries were involved in the murder.[1]

Murdered by the UVF, The UVF perceived him to be a member or an associate of the LVF. [2]

[1] 'Man shot dead in gun attack', BBC News, 18 May 2004

[2] Sixth Report of the Independent Monitoring Commission. 22 September 2005.

03-June-04 Kevin McAlorum 31 M ? INLA ? South Belfast  

Kevin McAlorum was ambushed by two gunmen who rammed his car at Derriaghy.  Detectives were examining a possible drugs motive for the attack.[1]

McAlorum had previously served three years of a 16year sentence for possessing a gun used in the murder of an INLA man.  He was released under the Good Friday Agreement [2]

The victim's sister, Barbara McAlorum was shot dead by INLA gunmen nine years earlier in 1996 [3]

 

[1] Drugs link to Belfast murder victim, UTV News, 3 June 2004

[2] Motive sought for school murder, BBC News, 04 June 2004

01-Oct-04 Darren Thompson 22 M Protestant   Unknown loyalist group Waterside, Derry Derry

Shot in the head as he walked to work on 29th Sept. and died on 1st Oct. [1]

Loyalist feud or fall-out between individual loyalists [2]

[1] Murderers 'vermin' says father, BBC News, 7 Oct. 2004

[2]Shot man 'killed by loyalist terrorists' Belfast Telegraph, 4 Nov. 2004

[3] Terror groups deny feud as man buried, Belfast Telegraph, 5 Oct. 2004

30-01-05 Robert McCartney 33 M Catholic None IRA members (unsanctioned) Markets area, Belfast  

currently being updated

Robert McCartney was drinking with friends at Magenniss’ bar when an altercation occurred between his group and some local IRA men. [1]   Robert McCartney and a friend, injured in the altercation, left the pub to go to hospital, when they were confronted by a group of men. [2] Robert McCartney and his friend were beaten by the gang, using sewer rods.  Robert McCartney was then stabbed in the heart and cut from his navel to breastbone; his friend was also stabbed but not fatally. [3] Robert McCartney died in hospital the following morning. [3] Some of those involved in the attack returned to the pub, cleaned the pub, hid their clothes and told those present not to talk about what they had seen. [3]

The police came under attack when they carried out searches in the Markets area, in the days after the murder. [4]  Few witnesses came forward in connection with the murder.  Gerry Adams of Sinn Féin stated that those involved could speak to the Police Ombudsman or a solicitor if they wished. [5]

The IRA issued several statements claiming that they were not involved in the murder, nor were they intimidating witnesses from coming forward. [6] They also offered to shoot those responsible. [10]

Sinn Féin suspended a number of members from the organisation for failing to provide witness statements. [7]

   

A number of arrests were made in connection with the killing.[8]

One man was charged with the murder of Robert McCartney and two others were charged with assault and affray. [9] 

[1] No punishment for IRA knife killers, by Suzanne Breen, The Village, 8 February 2005

[2] McCartney invoice helps rebut Provos fund smear, by Jim Cusack, Sunday Independent, 5 April 2005

[3] Grieving sisters square up to IRA, by Henry McDonald, The Observer, 13 February 2005

 [4] Brutal killing turns republicans against IRA, by Angelique Chrisafis, The Guardian, 9 February 2005

[5] Adams in appeal to catch killers, BBC News, 14 February 2005

[6] P O’Neill, Irish Republican Publicity Bureau, Dublin on CAIN Web Service, www.cain.ulst.ac.uk

[7] Sinn Féin suspends seven after bar murder, by Angelique Chrisafis, The Guardian, 4 March 2005

[8]  Fourth arrested in murder inquiry, BBC News, 2 February 2005

[9] McCartney murder trial to proceed, BBC News, 2 July 2007

[10] Full text of IRA statement, The Guardian, 8 March 2005

 

28-02-05 Lisa Dorrian 25 F Catholic LVF   Ballyhalbert Co. Down Lisa went missing from a party at a caravan site, leaving behind her handbag and personal belongings.  Despite the fact that her body has not been found, police are treating the case as a murder inquiry.   Three men arrested and questioned, but freed without charge. [1]

In June 2005 another man was arrested. [2]

[1] Lisa case cop: Tell us what you know, Sunday Life, 27 March 2005

 

[2] Man arrested in Lisa murder probe, BBC News, 14 June 2005

18- Mar-2005 Stephen Nelson 55 M       Glengormley, Belfast  

Nelson was assaulted in September 2004 by a group of around 10 men outside a nightclub where he worked as a doorman.  He never recovered consciousness and died six months later. [1]

The Independent Monitoring Commission has reported that the men who carried out the assault were members of the UDA. [2]

Eight men were taken for questioning but later released without charge.[3]

 

 

 

1] Reward offered over UDA linked murder, UTV News, 18 May 2005

[2] Fifth report of the Independent Monitoring Commission, 24 May 2005 

01-Jul-05 Jameson Lockhart 25 M     UVF East Belfast  

A gunman opened fire on the lorry that Lockhart was driving as he worked on the demolition of a bar, and he was hit in the chest four times.  Another man who was in the lorry escaped unhurt.  Lockhart had escaped a previous gun attack in January 2005 [1]

He had been the target of graffiti on the Shankill Road in the weeks prior to his death. [2]

He had been due to testify as the key witness in the trial of Paul Crooks for the attempt on his life in January.  Crooks had also been charged with membership of the UVF, although this charge had been dropped. [3]

Murdered by the UVF, The UVF perceived him to be a member or an associate of the LVF. [4]

 

Two men were arrested for questioning on 4th July. [1]

Three men from the Belfast area were questioned in April 2006, but released without charge[2]

[1] Feud fears after murder, Belfast Telegraph, 1 July 2005

[2] Feud fears, News Letter, 2 July 2005

[3]   Attempted murder charges dropped, BBC News, 8 July 2005

[4]  Belfast loyalist has attempted murder charge dropped, Online.ie, 8 July 2005

[5] Houses searched in murder inquiry, BBC News, 4 July 2005

[6] Sixth Report of the Independent Monitoring Commission. 22 September 2005.

[7] Three men released over killing, BBC News, 20 May 2006

11-Jul-05 Craig McCausland 19 M     UVF woodvale, North Belfast  

Three men burst into a house in Dhu Varren Park at 1:58 am and opened fire. [1]

McCausland was shot and died later in hospital.  The attack came only hours after another shooting on the Crumlin Road, blamed on the LVF, in which a man was seriously injured. [2]

A light blue Peogot 405, suspected of being used in the lethal attack was later found on fire. [3]

Murdered by the UVF, The UVF perceived him to be a member or an associate of the LVF. [4]

[5] However, the LVF confirmed that McCausland was not one of their members.

 

   

[1] Loyalists blamed for city murder, BBC News, 11July 2005

[2] UVF set to 'wipe out' rivals as feuding leaves teenager dead, Irish News, 12 July 2005

[3] Teenager killed as feud escalates, Belfast Telegraph, 11July 2005 

 

[4] Shootings North Belfast, PSNI Press Release, 11 July 2005

 

[5] Sixth Report of the Independent Monitoring Commission. 22 September 2005.

 

[6] Party is urged to sever UVF link, BBC News, 19 July 2005

30 -Jul-05 Stephen Paul 29 M   LVF UVF G.encairn, Belfast  

Paul was shot several times as he sat in a van, with a passenger, outside his father's house.  His passenger was injured. [1] His family deny he was connected to the LVF.  He had previously survived a murder attempt in January 1999. [2]

Murdered by the UVF, The UVF perceived him to be a member or an associate of the LVF. [3]

The victim's uncle, drug dealer William 'Wassy' Paul, was killed in 1999 by Red Hand Commando Frankie Curry, apparently over a personal grudge [4]

   

[1] Grim warning on loyalist feud, Belfast Telegraph, 01 August 2005

 

Loyalist is shot dead, Sunday Life, 31 July 2005

Sixth Report of the Independent Monitoring Commission. 22 September 2005.[2]

 

Loyalist is shot dead, by Sinead McCavana, The Belfast Telegraph, 31 July 2005 [3]

10-Aug-05 Thomas Devlin 15 M C     Somert on Road, North Belfast  

Thomas Devlin was stabbed to death while walking from the local shops with two friends.

His murder is believed to have a sectarian motive [1]

Devlin was killed after being stabbed in the back five times. (10) He was stabbed trying to climb over a fence to safety, and then again when he lay on the ground.  It was also alleged that he had been struck with a wooden bat. (12)

 

 

Two men and a male juvenile were arrested; and released without charge [1]

A man was arrested in connection with the murder, and later released without charge [2]

Nigel Brown, 24, was the only person, charged in connection with the incident. He was charged in relation to stabbing a friend of Thomas’s. However, after conducting a review of the case, the PPS stated that six key suspects could face charges of withholding information.

When Brown attended court to face the GBH charges, he was informed he would also be facing murder charges. Brown faced the charges based on circumstantial evidence. Brown’s defence barrister called the decision ‘outrageous’. (10)

Gary Ryan Taylor, 22, was also charged with the murder of Devlin and the attempted murder of Jonathan Mckee. (11)

 

[1]Killing 'sectarian', Daily Ireland

 

[2]Three arrested in murder inquiry, BBC News, 11.08.05

 

[3]Arrest after Devlin murder, UTV, 20.08.05

 

[4]Man released in Devlin murder probe, RTE News, 21.08.05

(9) Devlin suspects may face charges, Allison Morris, Irish News, 10 Sept 2008

(10) Court told of murder charge in Devlin case, Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 21 March 2009

(11) Man in court over Devlin murder, BBC News, 24 March 2009

(12) Devlin stabbed ‘climbing fence’, BBC News, 9 April 2009

 

15-Aug-05 Michael Green 42 M     UVF Sandy Row, South Belfast  

[1] Green was shot as he got off his motorbike outside his workplace at 8.15am 

[2] The police believe his death is linked to the ongoing LVF-UVF  feud

[3] LVF have denied Green was one of its members

[4] Murdered by the UVF, The UVF perceived him to be a member or an associate of the LVF

 

   

[1] Man is shot dead in city attack, BBC News, 15 August 2005  UVF is blamed for fatal shooting, BBC News, 15 August 2005

[2] Loyalists turf war claims fourth victim, UTV, 15 August 2005

[3] Police re-open road after killing, BBC News, 16 August 2005

[4] Sixth Report of the Independent Monitoring Commission. 22 September 2005.

 

04-Oct-05 Jim Gray 47 M P UDA UDA East Belfast  

 

Shot dead at his father’s house in East Belfast.  [1]

 

He had recently been released on bail, following money laundering charges. [2]

 

Police believe his murder is part of ‘internal housekeeping’ by UDA. [3]

 

 

 

Six men have been arrested. [4]

The UDA were formally accused of murdering Gray in a report by the Independent Monitoring Commission, submitted to the British and Irish government [5]

 

[1]Few tears as loyalist thugs kill their own. The Times. 06.10.05

 

[2] Murder of Gray was an ‘internal matter’. Newsletter. 05.10.05

 

[3] UDA blamed for murder of its ‘ex-brigadier’ Gray. Irish News. 05.10.05

 

[4] Ulster strongman’s fit a familiar pattern. Boston Globe 06.10.05

[5] UDA 'responsible' for man's murder, by Dan McGinn, The Irish Examiner, 02 February 2006

[6] Eighth Report of the Independent Monitoring Commission 01 February 2006

 

07-Nov-05 Martin Conlon 35 M C Previously Real IRA A faction of the Real IRA Farnaloy Road, Keady Co. Armargh

Mr Conlon, who was released 18 months ago from a 4yr prison sentence after being arrested at a Real IRA training camp. He was abducted from a friend's house by 2 men, shot with a stun gun and driven off. Later he was found unconscious by the roadside; he died in hospital from gunshot wounds to the head. [1]

Dectectives believe he was the victim of a fallout with former associates from Real IRA [2]

However, despite having spent time in jail for Real IRA offences it is believed that at the time of death he was no longer a member of the organisation [3]

3 men, 1 woman and a male juvenile were detained over the murder but 4 of them were released; police are still questioning one man [4]

   

[1] 'Total Shock at Shooting' by Connla Young, Daily Ireland

[2] 'Shot republican freed from jail last year' Ireland Online, 08 November 2005

[3] 'RIRA lint to Conlon murder' by Connla Young, Daily Ireland, 11 November 2005

[4] 'Five now held over Conlon murder' BBC News, 17 November 2005

[5] 'Four released in gun murder probe' BBC News, 18 November 2005

 

03-Feb-06 Gerard Devlin 39 M     Whitecliff Parades, Ballymurphy West Belfast

The victim was stabbed to death as he picked his children up.  Two other men, related to the victim were treated in hospital following the attack [1]

Devlin had move away from the area several months previously in an attempt to resolve a long-running dispute between himself and the Natarantonio family, which had involved several severe attacks over 3 years [2]

Following the murder, properties belonging to the Notarantonio family were attacked and set on fire.  Police searched houses, believed to be connected to the Notarantonio family [3]

The police currently state that there is nothing to suggest paramilitary involvement in the killing [4] 

The Devlin family believe the police are protecting an informer and have described the PSNI investigation as 'farcical'.  The Police Ombudsman is investigating the murder [5]

There has been ongoing violence in Ballymurphy since the murder, including petrol bombs and the non-fatal shooting of a teenager [6]

   

Four members of the Notarantonio family have been charged.  Paul Burns (23), Francisco Notarantonio (18), Christopher Notarantonio and his son William (21) were charged with murder and affray [1]

Christopher Notarantonio was released on bail on condition that he surrender his passport.  Following his claim that the passport was burnt during an arson attack on his home, Lord Justice Shiel has ordered that he report to police in England everyday [2]

Paul Burns was released on bail on the condition that he remains at an address in England [2]

[1] Man stabbed to death as children play in the street, Irish News, 06 February 2006

[2] Two men held over father of five's death, The Sunday Times, 05 February 2006

[3] Police probe murder 'fires link', BBC News, 05 February 2006

[4] Two more charged over Devlin killing, Irish News, 09 February 2006

[5] Police wary of passport claim, Irish News, 10 March 2006

[6] Bail for Devlin co-accused, Irish News, 16 March 2006

   
19-Feb-06 Thomas Hollran 49 M   UDA Carrickfergus (Woodburn Estate) County Antrim

Thomas Hollran was found in an alleyway with serious head and facial injuries.  He died later in hospital [1]

He had previously been ordered to leave Carrickfergus by the UDA, and his car and home had been attacked [2]

He was residing in Belfast and had returned to Carrickfergus to visit his family [3]

Three men have been arrested in connection with Hollran's murder [1]

Hollran's brother and Peter Callaghan have been charged with causing Hollran to leave his home by force, threats or menace in December 2005 [2]

[1]  Post-mortem due on murder victim, BBC News, 20 Februray 2006

[2] Terror group linked to murder probed, Belfast Telegraph, 21 February 2006

[3] UDA beat my brother to death, Irish News, 20 February 2006

[4] Arrests in town murder inquiry, BBC News, 22 February 2006

[5] Hollran brother charged, Irish News, 25 February 2006

   
04-April-06 Denis Donaldson 56 M C Sinn Fein Glenties County Donegal, Republic of Ireland

Denis Donaldson was found dead in his remote cottage which he had recently moved to, killed by four shotgun blasts to his chest, head and arms [1]

The IRA immediately denied any involvement in the killing.  The victims' family stated that they believed this, and instead blamed the activities of the British Intelligence [2]

Despite allegations that republicans are responsible (PIRA acting officially or individually, or dissident republicans), Bertie Ahern and Tony Blair indicated that they did not believe the killing was officially sanctioned by the IRA [3]

The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, Peter Hain, denied that British Intelligence was involved [4]

The killing took place two days before the endeavour by Blair and Ahern to revive power-sharing in the Stormont Assembly [5]

In 2002, whilst he was Sinn Fein's head of administration, Donaldson was arrested and accused of running a Sinn Fein spy ring at Stormont, which led to the collapse of power-sharing in Northern Ireland.  After a three year legal battle, charges against him and two others were dropped in "the public interest" [6]

In 2005, Donaldson was exposed as a British spy.  After admitting that he had been a paid agent for over 20 years, Donaldson was expelled from the party and moved to a relatives' house in Donegal [7]

He was allegedly warned by the Gardai that his life might be at risk and offered him advice about personal safety.  In March 2006 the Sunday World published a photograph of his cottage [8]

The Irish News claimed that a former member of the Real IRA led the Garda to the hiding place of sledgehammer that was believed to have been used to break into Donaldson’s cottage. It was hoped that the sledgehammer would contain forensic evidence. It was also revealed that since leading the Garda to the sledgehammer, the informant had survived a murder attempt and a pipe bombing at his home in Co Donegal. (9) He has since been put into Garda protective custody. (10)

A Real IRA representative claimed that the organisation was responsible for the murder. The representative says that the seven-strong Army Council debated at length whether Donaldson should be killed, but it was decided that he should in order to show that the organisation ‘weren’t prepared to tolerate traitors’. The representative said that they waited 3 years to make an announcement in order to ensure that they had ‘executed crown force personnel’ which they had achieved at Massereene. (11) 

In a Real IRA statement, the group gave the details of Donaldson’s death.  They said that on entering the cottage, there was a silent struggle but ‘he seemed to know what was coming to him’. They said that he had been under surveillance to ensure that he was alone. They said that he hadn’t been tortured or questioned. (12)

 

 

 

 

[1] Killers pumped four shots into IRA 'traitor' by Tom Brady and Anita Guidera, Irish Independent, 06 April 2006

[2] IRA 'not behind' ex-spy killing, BBC News Online, 07 April 2006

[3] Republican members suspected of killing Donaldson, by Gerry Moriarty and Dan Keenan, The Irish Times, 06 April 2006

[4] Hain: Uk intelligence not involved, Daily Mail, 06 April 2006

[5] Blair: Spy's murder will not ruin peace, by Michael Settle, The Herald, 06 April 2006

[6] The Execution: How an IRA man turned British spy met his brutal end, by David McKittrick, Independent Online, 05 April 2006

[7] Donaldson family release statement, UTV, 07 April 2006

(8) Dissident denies ‘key witness’ RIRA link, Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 17 April 2009

(09) Denis Donaldson informant kept hidden, Belfast Telegraph, 17 April 2009

(10) How Real IRA killed Denis Donaldson, Suzanne Breen, Tribune News, 14 April 2009

 

 

   
16-April-06 Steven Colwell 23 M        

Steven Colwell was shot as he drove through Ballynahinch. The car he was driving was allegedly stolen and had five passengers. [1]

 

Initially it appeared he was shot as he had failed to stop at a checkpoint. However, an eye-witness claimed that the car had stopped in traffic (just before the checkpoint), and was unable to go forward or reverse. [2] He was not armed. [1]

He was given the last rites by a Catholic priest, because he was wearing a Celtic top. [3] He was close friends with Johnny Adair’s son. [2] However, he had suffered punishment beatings from both the UVF and UDA. He had previously served 3 years for threatening to shoot a policeman. [4]

The Police Ombudsman has begun an investigation. Sir Hugh Orde, the Chief Constable will be questioned about the incident by the Policing Board. [3]

He was originally from the Shankill Rd, but had been living in Cullybackey for several months. [5]

The PSNI officer responsible has not been suspended from duty. [6]

Mark Fitzsimmons, who had been in the car at the time of the incident, was shot and wounded less than two months later.  Fitzsimmons (22) was shot twice in the hand and leg by masked gunmen in the Lenadoon estate, West Belfast [7]

 

 

[1] Police shooting: How could it happen? Belfast Telegraph. 17.04.06

[2] Cops kill unarmed loyalist. Irish Voice.

[3] PSNI chief to be quizzed on shooting of car driver. Belfast Telegraph. 21.04.06

 [4] Adair link to fatal shooting by police. Irish News. 18.04.06

[5] Colwell funeral takes place. Ulster TV. 24.04.06

[6] Probe into shooting at checkpoint. BBC News. 18.04.06

[7] Shooting victim was death-car passenger, by Barry McCaffrey, Irish News, 05 June 2006

 

   
08-May-06 Michael McIlveen 15 M     Ballymena Co-Atrim

 

Michael McIlveen was attacked with a friend in Ballymena, at 12.30am on Sunday 7 May 2006.  He was on his was home after buying a pizza, when he was confronted by a group, armed with a baseball bat. [1]

Michael McIlveen was chased through a number of housing estate areas and down an alleyway where he was attacked. (17) Whilst running away from the attackers, McIlveen had sought help from friends at a nearby party. (20)  Joe Lewis confronted McIlveen and his two friends in a car park in Harryville and subjected them to sectarian abuse. He was among the group who chased McIlveen into an alley and fought him there. [14]

Christopher Kerr obtained the baseball bat used in the beating from his nearby grandparent’s house.  He said that he had taken the bat to protect himself. (14)

After the attack, Joe Lewis also used the baseball bat to smash the gate of a nearby party.  (14)

Mervyn Moon was the only person to use the baseball bat to strike McIlveen. (14) He had ‘snatched the bat out of Kerr’s hands’ (18) He ‘nailed’ him with the baseball bat, swinging it overhead and also as if he were taking a golf swing. (16)

While Moon struck Michael McIlveen with the bat, the others ‘put the boot in’, in the process fracturing his skull on both sides. (16) McIlveen was kicked over 60 times (19)

In spite of the injuries, McIlveen stumbled over half a mile home. Once home, he went to bed, but his uncle Sean, thinking he was drunk, took photographs of him to embarrass him in the morning. The family did not become aware of his injuries until being told in a call that Michael had been a victim of ‘a brutal and savage attack’. (16)   His mother then called an ambulance. (2)

McIlveen died the following day as a result of a fractured skull and a blot clot in his brain. (16) 

The police treated the attack as sectarian.  [3]

Accusations against certain young individuals appeared on www.bebo.com shortly after the attack [5]

DUP leader Ian Paisley was invited to the funeral. [6]

Two 15 year-old girls were arrested for threatening a girl. The girl, who was a friend of Michael McIlveen's, was subjected to sectarian abuse. [7]

More than 1000 people attended the funeral, with many wearing Celtic and Rangers shirts to demonstrate cross-community solidarity [8]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

5 people were questioned in relation to the attack, including one juvenile [4]

The five were charged with the murder: Aaron Wallace, 18, Christopher Kerr, 19, an unnamed 15-year-old and two unnamed 17-year-olds. [8]

 

Two more teenagers, aged 15 and 16, were charged in connection with the murder.  The 15-year-old was charged with murder, and the 16-year- old with affray. [9]

Death threats were issued against seven of those initially charged with the murder [11]

A bail application for Mervyn Moon, one of the accused, was refused. [12]

However, Aaron Wallace was released on bail in November 2006 [13]

In total, seven men were charged with various offences by the police, including:

Christopher Kerr, 22. Christopher Kerr obtained the baseball bat used in the beating from his nearby grandparent’s house.  He had kicked McIlveen during the attack. He said that he was drunk and had taken a lot of diazepam.  He was the only defendant to testify.  Kerr was convicted of murder on 25/2/09.

Jeff Lewis, 19. Lewis had attacked McIlveen in an alleyway. Lewis was convicted of murder.

Aaron Wallace, 20. Wallace had kicked McIlveen in the alleyway. Wallace had gone to the police station voluntarily after the attack. Despite having a Catholic fiancé, he was known to organise fights with young Catholics in the area.  He was convicted of murder.

Mervyn Moon, 20.  Moon was the only person to strike McIlveen with a baseball bat.  He had also repeatedly kicked McIlveen.  He was convicted of murder.

Christopher McLeister, 18.  He was a local boxing champion.  He was convicted of manslaughter.

Peter McMullan, 18.  He was the youngest of the defendants, aged 15 at the time of the murder.  He was convicted of criminal damage for destroying a fence.

Paul Henson, 18.  Only defendant not originally charged with murder. Convicted of affray and criminal damage. (14)

PSNI Chief Constable Sir Hugh Orde asked the Attorney General to review the leniency of the sentences. Mr Justice Treacy said the maximum any of those convicted of murder should serve is 13 years. (15)

 

 

 

 

[1] Youth (15) beaten in sectarian attack dies, Irish Times, 09 May 2006

[2] Now its murder, Belfast Telegraph, 09 May 2006

[3] Murder probe as attacked boy dies, BBC News, 08 May 2006

[4] Five quizzed over Ballymena school boy murder, Ulster TV, 09 May 2006

[5] Hateful chat flares on student websites in wake of death, Irish Independent, 10 May 2006

[6] Family tells ‘supportive’ Paisley he’s welcome at Michael’s funeral,  Irish Independent,  12 May 2006

[7] Michael: Two teenage girls are arrested over sectarian threat. Belfast Telegraph, 13 May 2006

[8] Jeers as five teenagers accused of school boy’s murder charged,  Irish Independent, 12 May 2006

[9] Two more teens charged in relation to Ballymena murder, Irish News, 15 May 2006

[10] 'Sectarian' victim laid to rest, BBC News, 18 May 2006

[11] McIlveen suspects ‘under threat’, BBC News, 29 August 2006

[12] McIlveen accused held on remand, Irish News, 8 December 2006

[13] Teen murder accused granted bail, BBC News, 13 November 2006

 [14] Seven held days after killing – four now convicted of murder, Maeve Connolly, BBC News, 26 Feb 2009

[15] Orde challenges leniency of sentences in McIlveen killing, Allison Morris, Irish News, 8 May 2009

[16] McIlveen’s family finally see his killers convicted, Belfast Telegraph, 26 Feb 2009

[17] Teen ‘gone but not forgotten’, Karen Atkinson, BBC News, 25 Feb 2009

[18] I lied to police, McIlveen accused admits in court, Maeve Connolly, BBC News, 27 Jan 2009

[19] McIlveen kicked 60 times, says witness, Belfast Telegraph, 13 Nov 2008

 

[20] Shouts of help before Michael was murdered, Maeve Connolly, Irish News, 7 Oct 2008

 

 

 

 

   
29-July-06 Ronald Mackie 36 M P   Tobermore Co. Londonderry

Ronald Mackie had travelled to Northern Ireland to attend an Orange Order parade. It is believed a dispute occurred during a disco at Tobermore United Football Club. [1]

Mackie was assaulted by a gang of men, and then intentionally placed in the road. [2] He was hit by a red car, with a passenger on board the vehicle. [2]

The driver of the car which hit Mackie is believed to have stopped for a short time, before leaving again. [4]

Around 30 people are believed to have witnessed the attack. [3]

The UVF are suspected of being involved – the dispute was allegedly with a local loyalist commander, and the disco was a loyalist fundraiser. [5]

 

Seven men have been questioned regarding the attack. Of those, one has been arrested and released on bail, two have been released without charge, three have been charged in connection with the murder.[6] [7] [8]

On 7 August 2006, a fourth man was charged with the murder. [9]

Two women were arrested in September in connection with withholding information about the murder. [10]

 

[1] Three held in NI probe. Ulster Tv. 02.08.06

[2] Man is arrested in murder inquiry. BBC News. 30.07.06

[3] Thirty people may have seen attack on Scot in Londonderry. The Herald. 01.08.06

[4] Five held in NI murder probe. Ulster TV. 31.07.06

[5] Battered to Death by UVF. Daily Ireland. 01.08.06

[6] Four still questioned on murder. BBC News. 01.08.06

[7] Third man to face murder charge. BBC News. 03.08.06

[8] Teenager arrested in murder probe. BBC News. 03.08.06

[9] Fourth man charged with Mackie murder, Ulster Tv, 07.08.06

[10] Murder officers arrest two women, BBC News, 13 September 2006

 

   
22-Aug-06 Mark Christie 36 M   UDA/UVF Owen Roe Drive, Kilcooley Estate, Bangor County Down,NI

Mark Christie was found at 11:30pm [1]

He had been chased from behind a house and caught by a gang of six men, before being hacked to death in the middle of the street. A machete, screwdrivers and a hatchet were believed to have been used [2]

Christie had previously been ordered to stay away from the estate by loyalist paramilitaries. It is believed he had returned to the estate to see his girlfriend.[3]

Two men were arrested and questioned about the murder [4]

Four men were questioned about the murder. All were released without charge.[5]

Two further men were arrested in connection with the murder; and subsequently released [6]

Three men were arrested in County Down and released without charge.[7]

 

[1] Murder victim 'hacked to death', BBC News, 23.08.06

[2] Cocaine abuser brutally hacked to death by gang, Belfast Telegraph, 24.08.06

[3] Police quiz two over murder, Belfast Telegraph

[4] Loyalists blamed for hacking Bangor drug dealer to death, Irish News, 25.08.06

[5] Fourth man freed in murder probe, BBC News, 26.08.06

[6] Pair are released in murder probe, BBC News, 15.09.06

[7] Three held over murder released, BBC News, 30.01.07

 

 

   
10-Nov-06 Thomas O'Hare 33 M      

Foley road, Tassagh

 

Keady, County Armagh

Six men entered the home shared by Thomas O’Hare and Lisa McClatchey on 7 November 2006, doused them in a flammable liquid and set them on fire.[1] 

Subsequently, four brothers were admitted to hospitals in County Louth with serious

burns.[1]  It appeared that Thomas O’Hare and Lisa McClatchey had both been beaten with hammers before the  attack. [4] 

The PSNI wished to speak to anyone who had information about a number of cars seen in the area. [5]

 

The police raided a house in Clady and took items away for examination. [2] 

A 43 year old man was arrested, and charged with perverting the course of justice and withholding information. [3]

A woman was questioned about the attack. [7]  

A 24 year old man was questioned in relation to the murders and released on bail. [8]

 

 

[1] Possible fire link being examined, BBC News, 8.11.2006

[2] Fireball couple fighting for lives, Belfast Telegraph, 09. 11. 2006

[3] Man faces court over fire killing, BBC News, 12.11.2006

[4] Fire couple ‘beaten’ court hears, BBC News, 14.11.2006

[5] Tributes to blaze attack victim, BBC News, 15.11.2006

[6] Arson attack victim Lisa is critically ill, Belfast Telegraph, 14.11.2006

[7] Woman arrested after Armagh attack, Ulster TV, 18.11.2006

[8] Man quizzed over deaths is bailed, BBC News, 19.11.2006

 

   
15-Nov-06 Lisa McClatchey 21 F      

Foley road, Tassagh

 

Keady, County Armagh

 

Six men entered the home shared by Thomas O’Hare and Lisa McClatchey on 7 November 2006, doused them in a flammable liquid and set them on fire.[1] 

Subsequently, four brothers were admitted to hospitals in County Louth with serious burns.[1]

 It appeared that Thomas O’Hare and Lisa McClatchey had both been beaten with hammers before the  attack. [4]

The PSNI wished to speak to anyone who had information about a number of cars seen in the area. [5]

Lisa  McClatchey was the step-grandaughter of former District Master of Portadown Orange Lodge. [6]

 

The police raided a house in Clady and took items away for examination. [2]  A 43 

year old man was arrested, and charged with perverting the course of justice and withholding information. [3]

A woman was questioned about the attack. [7]  

A 24 year old man was questioned in relation to the murders and released on bail. [8]

 

[1] Possible fire link being examined, BBC News, 8.11.2006

[2] Fireball couple fighting for lives, Belfast Telegraph, 09. 11. 2006

[3] Man faces court over fire killing, BBC News, 12.11.2006

[4] Fire couple ‘beaten’ court hears, BBC News, 14.11.2006

[5] Tributes to blaze attack victim, BBC News, 15.11.2006

[6] Arson attack victim Lisa is critically ill, Belfast Telegraph, 14.11.2006

[7] Woman arrested after Armagh attack, Ulster TV, 18.11.2006

[8] Man quizzed over deaths is bailed, BBC News, 19.11.2006

   
12-Mar-07 Edward Burns 36       Falls Road area West Belfast

 

The victim was shot in the back of the head in the early hours of the morning. [1]

Police are searching for a silver Skoda registration PKZ 3760, or anyone who may have seen the vehicle. Police searches of the area have found a shotgun and handgun.  [2]

It’s believed the Continuity IRA may be involved with the killing and that the murder is connected to the murder of Joe Jones. [3]

An INLA source denied responsibility for the murders but alleged that the deaths were a result of an internal feud between the Continuity IRA over stolen weapons used for ‘unauthorised freelance jobs’. [4]

 A suspect in the murder escaped arrest by police. The suspect abandoned a car and fled from the area. The police pursued him, and then fired six shots when he refused to halt. [5]

Edward Burns had recently left the CIRA to form his own splinter group, the Irish People’s Liberation Army (IPLA) along with Joe Jones. [8]

According to a media report, two men telephoned Edward Burns and arranged to meet him to demand access to an arms dump that he knew of.  When he refused to give this information the two men shot him. [8]

Witness Damien O’Neill claimed that Gerard Mackin had abducted Burns in Burn’s own taxi. O’Neill says that Mackin ordered Burns to stop the car and get out. Mackin then told Burns to get on the ground where he pleaded with Mackin to spare his life. (10) O’Neill then said that Mackin then ‘just walked over and shot Eddie in the back of the head’. O’Neill said that he grabbed the gun from Mackin and tried to run away before being tripped up. Mackin then shot O’Neill in the arm and neck before the gun jammed. O’Neill then managed to stagger away to a taxi. (9)

 

 

Four people in total have been arrested and are being questioned in relation to the murder of Edward Burns.  [6]

A man and women were arrested following searches of a house in the White Parade area of West Belfast. A  firearm was taken with a number of other items. [7]

The group responsible for the killing, the Continuity IRA, promised not to harm or intimidate a witness (Damien O’Neill) who agreed to testify against one of their members (Gerard Mackin from West Belfast). This was done with the additional protection of the Garda and PSNI. It was claimed that this was agreed after the CIRA were ‘horrified and embarrassed’ by the killing. (8)

Gerard Mackin also faced charges of the attempted murder of Damien O’Neill. (9)

It was also claimed that the CIRA’s army council had wanted to ‘court marshal’ Mackin but instead decided to let the police investigate him. (10)

It was the first time that someone had been tried in a Special Criminal Court in Dublin for a murder committed in Northern Ireland. (11)

 

 

 

[1]Dissident backdrop to killings, BBC News, 13 March 2007.

[2] Car clue sought in murder inquiry, BBC News, 14 March 2007.

[3]Dissident republicans may be linked to murders, Gerry Moriarty, The Irish Times, 13 March 2007.

[4] INLA: We didn’t kill those men, Damien McCarney, Andersontown News, 16 March 2007.

 [5] Police Closing in on suspect in double murder investigation,  Claire McNeilly and Deborah McAleese, Belfast Telegraph, 15 March 2007.

[6] Searches linked to killings yield arrests, Staff Reporter, Irish News, 22 March 2007

[7] Police quiz pair over Belfast murder, Ulster TV, 22 March 2007.

[8] Republican community appalled by gruesome murders, Suzanne Breen, Sunday Tribune, 19 March 2007

(9) Republican terror group kept murder witness safe, John Mooney, Times Online, 30 Nov 2008

(10) Trial makes history, Irish News, 31 Oct 2008

(11) NI man tried for murder in Dublin, BBC News, 30 July 2008

 

   
12-Mar-07 Joe Jones M       Ardoyne North Belfast

 

The victim’s body was discovered about 8.00am near Elmsfield Street, North Belfast. [1]

The victim was badly beaten with a spade and received severe head injuries. [2]

He was beaten so severely that police were finding it difficult to identify the man. A priest who gave the man last rites also said it was impossible to recognise him. [3]

It’s believed the Continuity IRA may be involved in the killing, and that the murder is connected to the murder of Edward Burns.  [4]

AN INLA source denied responsibility for the murders but alleged that the deaths were a result of an internal feud between the Continuity IRA over stolen weapons used for ‘unauthorised freelance jobs’. [5]

A suspect in the murder escaped arrest by police. The suspect abandoned a car and fled from the area. The police pursued him, and then fired six shots when he refused to halt. [6]

Joe Jones had recently left the CIRA  to form his own splinter group, the Irish People’s Liberation Army (IPLA) along with Edward Burns. [8]

According to a media report, the two perpetrators went to find Joe Joes after killing Edward Burns for not providing information regarding an arms dump to which he had access. [8]

Joe Jones, who also had information and access to the arms dump, refused to give the perpetrators this information. The perpetrators  then attempted to shoot Joe Jones, however their gun jammed, and so they severely beat him with a spade. The suspects had a spade with them to dig up the weapons from the arms dump. [8]

 

Four people in total have been arrested and are being questioned in relation to the murder of Joe Jones.  [7]

 

[1]Dissident republicans may be linked to murders, Gerry Moriarty, The Irish Times,  13 March 2007

[2] INLA: We didn’t kill those men, Damien McCarney, Andersontown News, 16 March 2007.

[3] Two Killings, many questions, Deborah McAleese,  Belfast Telegraph 13 March 2007

[4] Dissident republicans may be linked to murders, Gerry Moriarty, The Irish Times,  13 March 2007

[5] INLA: We didn’t kill those men, Damien McCarney, Andersontown News, 16 March 2007.

[6] Police Closing in on suspect in double murder investigation, Claire McNeilly and Deborah McAleese, Belfast Telegraph, 15  March 2007.

[7] Searches linked to killings yield arrests, Staff Reporter, Irish News, 22 March 2007

[8] Republican community appalled by gruesome murders, Suzanne Breen, Sunday Tribune, 19 March 2007

   
03-Jun-07 Bryan James McGlynn 28 M   INLA? Fountainhill, Waterside Derry, Northern Ireland

Brian McGlynn was shot several times by two masked men who broke into his house at 4:00am.  [1] He died from a gunshot wound to the chest. [2]

He was at home with his girlfriend.  She was not injured in the shooting. [3]

The perpetrators escaped in a car, believed to be a green Vauxhall Cavalier – they crossed the Craigavon Bridge and turned into Abercorn Road.  [4]

Brian McGlynn was a doorman at Red Rooms, a nightclub in Derry. [5]

The INLA claimed the murder.  They said that Brian McGlynn has been using the organisation’s name for drug-dealing.  However, some sources continue to suspect the involvement of both PIRA and loyalists. [6]

The allegations of drug-dealing were denied by his father. [7]

Barry McGlynn’s mother said that her son ‘met some bad characters’ and that ‘he was certainly used by older men in an awful way’, in particular encouraging McGlynn to be aggressive towards heavy drug dealers at the nightclub at which he worked. (8) 

CCTV recordings of the vehicles used by the murderers (a purple Vauxhall Corsa and a dark Ford Escort) showed that the killers had taken just 36 seconds to break down the door, rush up a flight of stairs, shoot McGlynn and then return to the cars. (9)

 

 

Three men, all from Derry, were arrested in connection with the murder. [3]

Two further men were arrested in connection with the murder.  The men came from the loyalist Fountain estate – the police were criticised by community leaders for the extensive searches which accompanied the arrests. [6] 

All five men were subsequently released without charge. [4] 

In November 2008, two men were arrested in connection with the murder.  One of those arrested is also being questioned about INLA membership. [9]

Two of those arrested in November 2008 were released; a 46-year old man is still being questioned. [10]

 

[1] Masked gunmen murder doorman lying in his bed, by Bimpe Fatogun and Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 4 June 2007

[2] A professional hit? By Stephen Breen and George Jackson, Belfast Telegraph, 4 June 2007

[3] Trio held in doorman murder probe, BBC News, 4 June 2007

[4] Two more released over gun murder, BBC News, 5 June 2007

[5] Father had to identify dead son by his eyes, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 6 June 2007

[6] Police reject criticism of Derry arrests, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 7 June 2007

[7] INLA threaten drug-dealers and admit killing doorman, Suzanne Breen, Sunday Tribune, 17 June 2007

[8] Father of murdered man defends son, by Seamus McKinney, Irish News, 19 June 2007

[9] Second arrest in murder inquiry, BBC News, 20 November 2008

[10] Pair released in murder inquiry, BBC News, 20 November 2008

(11) Mother who still cant visit grave awaits information, Belfast Today, 25 Feb 2009

(12) Londonderry man ‘killed in seconds’, Sam McBride, Belfast Today, 25 Feb 2009

 

 

   
20-Oct-07 Paul Quinn 21 M    IRA members (unsanctioned)  Castleblaney, Co Monaghan Republic of Ireland

Paul Quinn was found  badly beaten at a farmhouse outside Castleblaney.  He died later in